(note: the quotes in this message have been trimmed down to relevant
context and rearranged)

On Sun, 2026-10-04 at 13:00 -0700, Edward Murphy via agora-discussion wrote:
>        When one or more persons satisfy at least one Winning Condition
>        and do not satisfy any Losing Conditions, all such persons win
>        the game.  The game CANNOT be won in any other way, rules to the
>        contrary notwithstanding.

The "when" here is unclear to me because "satisfiying at least one
Winning Condition and not satisfying any Losing Conditions" is a
continuous state, not an event.

> Re-enact Rule 2245 (Win by Not Losing) with Power 1 and this text:
> 
>        While a player is the only active player not to satisfy at least
>        one Losing Condition, e satisfies the Winning Condition of
>        Solitude.
> 
>        Cleanup procedure:  The same person cannot satisfy this Winning
>        Condition again until at least one other player ceases to
>        satisfy any Losing Condition.

> Re-enact Rule 2134 (Win by Clout) with Power 2 and this text:
> 
>        Upon a win announcement that a specified player's voting strength
>        on an ordinary decision initiated at that time would exceed the
>        combined voting strength of all other players on that decision,
>        the specified player satisfies the Winning Condition of Clout.
> 
>        Cleanup procedure:  No player can satisfy this Winning Condition
>        again during the same month.

Solitude and Clout are two of my favourite win conditions (although
Clout generally needs some amount of purchasable voting limit
manipulation to work properly), so I would enjoy seeing them back.

It's worth noting that the cleanup procedure on Solitude was buggy (and
still is in this proto), and this has been exploited in the past. A
better cleanup procedure would be to only reset once a significant
proportion of players had ceased to satisfy Losing Conditions.

Clout's can also be potentially buggy if you trigger a Win by Clout
right at the end of the month (although this one historically wasn't
exploited, AFAIR). Usually the best cleanup from Clout is to reset
voting limits, but that depends on what mechanism is being used to
manipulate them in the first place.

> Amend Rule 2614 (Eclipse Light) by replacing this text:
> 
>          - Cause one or more players to win Agora.
> 
> with this text:
> 
>          - Cause one or more players to satisfy Winning Conditions.
>          - Cause one or more players to cease to satisfy Losing
>            Conditions.

"Cause to cease to satisfy Losing Conditions" seems potentially very
buggy to me, because losing conditions are normally a consequence of
something rather than a status on their own. For example, if you make
"having been inactive in the last week" a Losing Condition, does
causing that pereson to cease to satisfy Losing Conditions cause them
to retroactively have been active for the last week?

>        Upon doing so, e satisfies the Winning Condition of Collection.

We should probably be using the same names in the rules as we do on the
Herald's Report, in order to avoid the common situation where two
effectively equivalent wins are categorized differently and later have
to be merged.

> Amend Rule 2438 (Ribbons) by replacing this text:
> 
>        While a person owns all types of Ribbon, that person can Raise a
>        Banner by announcement. This causes that person to win the game.
>        When a person wins this way, for each type of Ribbon, that
>        person's <type> Ribbon Ownership is flipped to False.
> 
> with this text:
> 
>        Upon owning all types of Ribbon, a person satisfies the Winning
>        Condition of Renaissance. (Cleanup procedure: For each person
>        satisfying this condition and each type of Ribbon, eir <type>
>        Ribbon Ownership is flipped to False.)

Apparently, some people care about the ability to delay a Win by
Renaissance. So this should likely require a win announcement rather
than happening automatically.

> Amend Rule 2646 (Activity) by appending this text:
> 
>        Having been inactive within the past week is a Losing Condition.

I'm generally against punishments for inactivity. We don't use the
status nearly as much as we should, and that's partly because being
inactive locks you out from too much of the game, so I'd prefer to not
make the situation worse.

> Re-enact Rule 2312 (The Pariah) with Power 1.7 and this text:
> 
>        The Pariah is an elected office, with no reports. Whenever a
>        player becomes the Pariah, that player is awarded 23 Blots.
> 
>        If more than 6 Blots are destroyed in the Pariah's possession in
>        any given week, the Pariah is awarded a sufficient number of
>        Blots in order to bring eir net Blot loss that week up to no
>        more than 6.
> 
>        Players are ENCOURAGED to enforce penalties for rules breaches
>        against the Pariah, even really minor ones.
> 
>        Upon a win announcement that the Pariah has ever continuously
>        had 0 Blots for an entire week whilst being the Pariah for all
>        of that time, then the Pariah satisfies the Winning Condition of
>        Cleanliness. Cleanup condition: The office of Pariah becomes
>        vacant and that player ceases to satisfy this Winning Condition.

Maybe under the current rules this should be sortitioned?

It's worth noting that this was originally proposed as a part of a scam
(introducing a number of Blot-equivalents into the economy was helpful
to the scam for reasons I can no longer remember, although Solitude
might have been relevant). As such, there was at least one intentional
bug (the one I remember is that if someone gets close to winning like
this, other players can stop it by voting em out of the office, but
they still retain the Blots afterwards). There's also the issue that
the optimal way to play it is likely to avoid responsibilities as much
as possible (to rebalance this, we may want to pay officers in some
currency that's useful for removing Blots, encouraging the Pariah to
take on additional offices).

This is also very related to (and inspired) the current Aggression
mechanic, and should likely be linked into that rather than being its
own mechanic.

> Re-enact Rule 2287 (Props) with Power 1 and this text:
> 
>        Props are a currency.
> 
>        The Air Traffic Controller is an office and the recordkeepor of
>        props.
> 
>        Ownership of props is limited to players.  Props CANNOT be
>        created, transferred, or destroyed except as allowed by this rule
>        or required by the rules in general.
> 
>        Once per week, each player CAN transfer a prop from one player
>        to another, provided that e explains why e chose each player,
>        and does not transfer it to emself.
> 
>        At the beginning of each quarter, one prop in the possession of
>        each player possessing more than fourteen props is destroyed,
>        and one prop is created in the possession of each player
>        possessing less than fourteen props.
> 
>        Players with at least 19 props are Pilots; the Pilot with the
>        most props (if any) is the Captain. Players with less than 9
>        props are Marines.  As soon as possible after any of these
>        statuses change, the Air Traffic Controller SHALL announce it.
> 
>        Upon a win announcement that one or more players each possess at
>        least 30 props, all those players satisfy the Winning Condition
>        of Respect.
> 
>        Cleanup procedure: All props are destroyed and 14 props are
>        created in the possession of each player.
> 
> [Removes "first-class". Moves initial allocation to Rule 2499.]
> 
> Amend Rule 2499 (Welcome Packages) by adding this text after the item
> about gaining spendies:
> 
>        * gains 14 props;

This rule has been a recurring rule (or occasionally contract, as it
can be done "unofficially" even without rules support) throughout a
significant portion of Agora's history, and has generally been
reflavoured each time it was re-enacted, so we might want to come up
with new flavour for it. (I did like the version which used "kudo", as
the singular of "kudos".) I think it works better when the tracking
asset doesn't do anything, though (this encourages players to freely do
transfers based on who they find helpful and/or annoying, rather than
trying to use them strategically or economically).

Note that there's a bug in this wording of the proposal (it initializes
props for new players but not existing players, so everyone would start
at 0).


-- 
ais523

Reply via email to