>
> What is your definition of "property"?
> Mine is: "Anything subject to human control."

What is your definition of "stealing?"
Mine is: depriving another person of possession of his property.

Copyright violation does not deprive another person either of possession or
use ("control") of his property.  It might reduce his opportunities for
profit (opportunity cost), but this is profit from a temporary legal
monopoly--perhaps an entirely legitimate monopoly from a utilitarian point
of view, but monopoly privileges nonetheless.  If GM is not permitted to
have a monopoly on auto manufacturing, thus depriving them of some
opportunities to profit, is this stealing their property? Of course not,
because no one has an inherent right to a monopoly.  I'm not stealing from
the barber if I cut my own hair, or persuade a mother,  girlfriend, or
whoever to do it for me for free, even if the cut is indistinguishable from
the local barber's own work, and even if it deprives the barber of profit
opportunities.   Monopolies, such as copyrights and patents, are granted
solely for reasons of superior social utility--namely, to encourage creative
work which might not otherwise be performed.  (I expect this was a valuable
law in a pre-industrial society in which 90% of the  population were
employeed as farm workers.  I'm not sure it has much value in a highly
industrialized economy wherein most people are city dwellers, half the
citizenry enrolls in college,  farmers are less than 3% of the population,
and technology is fast making many of these monopolies unenforceable.)

 But what is the optimum tradeoff between incentives created by granting
these temporary monopolies and removing or reducing the incentives so as to
promote more quickly the spread of innovation and knowledge throughout
society?  As soon as we ask this question, it becomes possible to challenge
existing copyright or similar laws, which were created purely for
utilitarian reasons, on  utilitarian grounds as well as  libertarian.

~Alypius Skinner
.

Reply via email to