> In any case, all of the deficiencies in children's brains you point out
> more or less sound like extensions of their low absolute IQ.

Not really. One listed deficiency is memory. That might be correlated with
IQ, but it's certainly not the same as IQ. Analogy: a computer with a
small storage capacity might have sophisticated software (analogy with
low memory/high IQ).

Real world example: Autistic children. Their behavior is described
as "misbehavior" because they simply can't learn how to interact with
adults. However, they can perform very complex tasks such as math
problems and some autistic people have been able to score well on IQ
tests. 

Abother real world example: In the book "Descarte's Error," a well
adjusted rail road worker in the 19th century is injured on the job. He 
recieves a severe trauma to the head which results in localized
brain damage. According to the author, the part of the brain which
was damaged many scientists believe is responsible for producing
emotions, which may conflict with detached rationalist thinking. 
Once the railroad worker recovered from his injury, he abandoned his
job, started to consort with criminals and lived the rest of his
life as a con-artist. As far as people could tell, he retained his
cognitive abilities but his personality completely changed.

My conclusion from such facts is that the ability to conduct normal
social interactions is a combination of learning, IQ, percpetion,
memory and other mental abilities. You really can't bundle them
all together. Child misbehavior is not reducible to IQ, but might
be a result of one or more of a deficiency in one or more of these
mental abilities. A simple economic model really seems to leave
a lot out. 

Fabio


Reply via email to