I completely agree. Tamil Ghajini wasnt that great.... Couldnt sit in the theatres for X Machi Y Machi song, and Rahatulla...
Hindi is CLASS. On Tue, Nov 25, 2008 at 6:42 PM, Dinesh <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Dude, whats so great about the Tamil version man??? i dun get it... r > u guys alright????except for that Suttum Vizhi, i dun find anything > listenable in Tamil Ghajini. Oru Maalai was not bad too, but was > annoying with the dance and all. > > My fren, Tamil Ghajini eventually faced WORSE fate when the audio was > released, even the reviews at that time [when the audio was freshly > released], it was bashed from right to left, front, bottom and middle! > > > http://sambharmafia.blogspot.com/2005/08/ghajini-music-review-observations.html > > READ THE COMMENTS BELOW AS WELL!!! > > so? the conclusion is, stop critisizing ARR's Ghajini when the so > called ONE OF THE BEST WORK IN INDIAN INDUSTRY was trashed initially > as well..... > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, > "Aaditya\(Addy\) *COOL*" > <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > Hi Rahmanics, > > Long wait for the album just couldn’t pay off. Ghajini has > > been one of the average albums of A.R.Rahman so far though the album is > > completely different from the original one but Rahman just > couldn’t manage to > > outdo Harris Jeyraj's Ghajini. Rahman had been very impressive in > Jodhaa Akbar, the music > > was a class. ADA and JTYJN too were > > typical Rahman albums. Last month's Yuvvraaj was also good but > definitely not > > one of his finest work. Even CD sales didn’t look encouraging for > Yuvvraaj but > > overall it was very good stuff. But what can I say for Ghajini, I > think Rahman > > was not in mood of composing this album. Rahman should have been > very careful > > in handling this project because the kind of music which Harris > Jeyraj had > > delivered in Tamil version was one of the greatest works in terms of > music in > > Indian Cinema. You just can’t compare that with the recently > released Hindi > > Ghajini. Very interesting to see Joginder Tuteja giving very high > rating for > > this album instead he should have given it for Jodhaa Akbar, 4/5 for > Ghajini is > > too much. I think he tried to play safe this time. > > > >             I got the copy yesterday and listened to it > atleast 8 times but still I didn’t find any > > songs better except Behka and Guzarish (not as good as Suthum > Vizhium though). > > Behka is uniquely refreshing number by Rahman with great vocal > rendering by Karthik. Karthik rocks in Behka. About the Rest it will > take very long time to grow on you. > > > > > >  > > > > 1. Guzarish â€" Good one but not the best, Javed Ali's voice > > is ok-ok. (3/5) > > > > 2. Aye Bachchu - No comments, X-micchi Y-micchi was better. > > (2/5) > > > > 3. Kaise Mujhe â€" Dissappointing. (2/5) > > > > 4. Behka - Only song I liked, Rahman managed to compose this > > song well. (4/5) > > > > 5. Latoo - Oh my god what was Rahman trying to do in this > > song. Rahmanji please don’t try to experiment too > > much. (2.75/5) > > > > 6. Kaise Mujhe (instrumental) is not as good as previous > > Rahman’s instrumental tracks. (2.5/5) > > > >  > > > > Album Rating: 2.5/5 . Top songs: Behka, > > Guzarish. Keeping finger crossed for BGMs. > > > >  > > > > Rahman gave 3 hit albums this year, Jodhaa Akbar, JTYJN and > > Sakkarakatti. Yuvvraaj was good album but couldn’t create magic as > Taal > > in terms of audio sales. ADA ’s > > sales were very bad too. Ghajini, I don’t know but by the way > Rahman had > > delivered music it too might fall down badly. It all depends on how > the songs > > have been shot and whether the songs are fitting to the situation > and most > > important thing of all will “Aamir Khan†factor help boost the > album sales. > > Rahman had been consistently impressive with the following directors: > > > > ManiratnamShankarAshutosh > > Gowariker > > > > Leaving the above 3 directors Rahman had given very few good > > albums. > > > > > > > > Among the 6 albums of A.R.Rahman released this year (Jodhaa > > Akbar, ADA , JTYJN, Sakkarakatti, > > Yuvvraaj, Ghajini) Jodhaa Akbar is the best. Yuvvraaj and JTYJN were > also good.Finally Rahman who started year with rich music concludes > > very badly. I would better listen to all his earlier albums all over > again > > instead of listening Ghajini’s music. > > > > > > > > > > Note: > > This was my personal feeling I always liked ARR's album but > Ghajini's music somehow > > didn't convince me. > > > > > > Regards,Aditya > > > > > > > > > > > > Add more friends to your messenger and enjoy! Go to > http://messenger.yahoo.com/invite/ > > > > > -- regards, Vithur
