|
Rajen:
Maybe you could use the word "egalitarian" society -- i.e having or showing
the same sets of beliefs that all men are equal and should have equal rights and
advantages.
Anjan
P.S. I like the term "janji mukhia". Didn't know its usage even
though I have heard it being used.
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Saturday, February 05, 2005 8:51
AM
Subject: Re: [Assam] Wave of
Prodigals?
> All I am saying is that Barua more than likely
used > the word 'secular' instead of maybe a word like >
'democratic'. Now, of course, Barua would have to > clarify what he was
really thinking.
Netters must excuse me. I misused the word 'secular'.
May be I should have used the word 'non-political-party' or something like
that. (I would request any netters to come up with the right word and help
me.) You see, I cannot use the word 'non-political' either because what we
are discussing is in fact politics. So I should say it is a
Janji-mukhia slip meaning I learnt my English, which as you know is not my
mother tongue, in Janji Mukh and make such silly mistakes from time to
time. But if Chandan insists that I intentionally used the word 'secular'
meaning non religious to create a confusion, then also I would say that due
to my Janji-mukhia English, probably I mistook the scared organizations
like BJP, Congress, ULFA, which Chandan was trying tinvoke, to be
'religions' because one need to have some type of 'belief system; to become
members of these too. Either way, it is entirely my fault, and I pray
netters, specially Chandan who seem to be utterly confused with my use of
the word, to excuse me in this case. I promise to try not to do any
more this type of Janji-mukhia slips in future.
Rajen
Barua
----- Original Message ----- From: "ram Sarangapani" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Chan
Mahanta" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Alpana B.
Sarangapani" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Cc:
<[email protected]> Sent:
Friday, February 04, 2005 3:45 PM Subject: Re: [Assam] Wave of
Prodigals?
> C'da, > > > Are you suggesting that
I am SPINNING what Rajen > > might have intended to
say? > > Not at all. > > > The word 'secular' has
been a lightning-rod of > > controversy in Assam Net for years on
end. So one > > might presume the meaning of the word is not
a > > mystery to these netters. > > I agree. But you are
giving me far too much credit. > All I am saying is that Barua more than
likely used > the word 'secular' instead of maybe a word like >
'democratic'. Now, of course, Barua would have to > clarify what he was
really thinking. > > All I did was to substiute democratic for
secular and > I could understand what he was talking about.
Frankly, > I think Barua just used the wrong word here - thats >
all. > > > Also should I have railed about Alpana asking
me > > the question about returning to Assam this > >
morning, because it was a 'personal' question? > > First, let me
clarify, I seriously doubt if Alpana or > I would think this as
personal, if someone were to ask > such a question. In fact, I think its
quite valid, > given the subject matter. > > But if you were
to go back and look at her question, > you would know that she was
really suggesting you to > include the question in your survey. I did
not get the > feeling she was asking 'you' personally. Of course
you > went ahead and answered it - of what "you" would do >
instead of the survey itself. Of course, she would > have to clarify - I
will leave this to her. > > > Did you, Rajib, Rajen not charge
me of 'evading' > > Rajen's question about the educational >
> achievements of the South issue? And when I > > answered, under
harassment, was that getting > > personal? > > Again, I
did not see them as being personal. If I did, > I wouldn't ask in the
first place. > > > >is a democratic forum, where members
could voice > > >opinions for/against any topic and that we
should > > >avoid personal references. > > When I said
the above, I was trying ONLY to > discern/interpret what Barua was
trying to say. He did > write several times that he felt the exchanges
were > personal. It was in that reference that I used it. I >
guess it was a poor attempt. But those are not my > ideas of exchanges.
My views are slightly different. > > > Did you, Rajib, Rajen
not charge me of 'evading' > > Rajen's question about the
educational > > achievements of the South issue? > > I
hope you really did not take that as personal-:) > I enjoyed those
banters, and still do (even if I am on > the losing
side). > > But, C'da, if I am allowed in the net, I would
always > tend to ask those questions to you or others. And I >
would also expect others to ask me too. I thought that > was the essence
of the net. Correct me if I am wrong > > C'mon, C'da, I write on
the net because I enjoy it, > learn somthing on the way, exchange ideas.
Sometimes > passionately, other times I am caustic, but NEVER in >
anger. > > --Ram > > > --- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
wrote: > > > Ram: > > > > Are you suggesting
that I am SPINNING what Rajen > > might have intended to
say? > > > > > > The word 'secular' has been a
lightning-rod of > > controversy in Assam Net for years on end. So
one > > might presume the meaning of the word is not a > >
mystery to these netters. > > > > > > Assuming it
is a mystery still to Rajen or Alpana > > then all the arguments BOTH
made for or against > > secularism in Indian governance were based
on > > very distorted perceptions on the meaning of >
> that word on their parts, wouldn't you think? > > >
> > > >is a democratic forum, where members could voice >
> >opinions for/against any topic and that we should > >
>avoid personal references. > > > > > > Did I
force anything on Assam Netters to stifle > > that? >
> > > Also should I have railed about Alpana asking me >
> the question about returning to Assam this > > morning, because
it was a 'personal' question? > > > > > > Did you,
Rajib, Rajen not charge me of 'evading' > > Rajen's question about
the educational > > achievements of the South issue? And when
I > > answered, under harassment, was that getting > >
personal? > > > > I do acknowledge here however that I used
strong > > language. I knew enough words and phrases to use >
> in lieu of the ones I did. In that I stand > > contrite. >
> > > > > > > >It shouldn't matter if >
> >someone is for/against GOI or Ulfa or something > >
else, > > >we should all have that voice to express, and >
> really > > >don't expect to be shouted down. >
> > > > > Is that what I was guilty of -- shouting
down > > someone--to invite the charge of attempting to > >
undermine the 'secularity' of Assam Net and > > injecting something
alien to the net, namely > > politics ? > > >
> > > Come on Ram. You are trying too hard, but not very >
> effectively. > > > > > > >Its difficult to
see > > >some of the most senior members bring out their >
> >rancour in an open forum. > > > > > > I
would agree with you on that. It is not good. > > I certainly
am not enjoying it. > > > > > > > >
> > > >My MO is very simple, when I read views from >
> readers - > > >I try very hard to read them at face value,
without > > >regard to what may or may not be their
political > > >beliefs off the net > > >
> > > Easier said than done. But even if I gave you a > >
pass on that, Rajen himself wrote several times > > indicating why he
is undertaking the effort on > > establishing a list of Assam's
Problems. I was > > not using anything at all culled from OFF-the
NET > > sources, confidential or otherwise. > > > >
But our conversations, debates, shouting matches > > and even the
fights are like a part of a never > > ending story. To pretend they
are stand alone, > > un-related islands of discourse would be
highly > > unpersuasive. > > > > > >
> >(I guess), but when > > >talking about 'problems'
in Assam, I really do not > > >look for some ulterior
motives. > > > > > > I won't argue with you on
that. By and large few > > do. But on this point of contention if I
remember > > correctly, ulterior motive assignments have been >
> flying right and left. Not that it bothers me. I > > know how to
defend myself.And I make no apologies > > for my leanings. But there
are others who might > > get offended when the boomerangs return home
or > > their protestations of neutrality get challenged. >
> > > > > >I also try very hard not to take anything
said > > against > > >my views on a personal
basis. > > > > > > I agree. It has always worked
for me. But then > > again I have 40 mil.th. naugahide skin (
now > > don't twist it and call it Noga-hide. We have > >
enough problems with them ). And gets thicker by > > the day from
accumulating scar tissue. > > > > > >
Finally: Can I give my assessment of what Rajen > > and Alpana
might have been attempting to say: " > > You are trying to create a
split between Assam > > and India by encouraging them to share
their > > views on this poll. We don't like that." >
> > > > > If that is so, why are they squeamish
about > > saying it like it is? What are they afraid of? > >
Are they afraid I might turn the ULFA on them to > > teach them a
lesson ? > > > > > > And if they did, I might say
something like:' > > Yes, yes, it was me who started it all. My
bad! > > So sue me.' > > > > > > >
> c-da :-) > > > > > > > > >
> > > > > > > > > At 11:29 AM -0800
2/4/05, ram Sarangapani wrote: > > >C'da > >
>> Neither you nor Rajen have done it yet, leaving > >
> > myself and I am sure a host of other netters > >
>>wondering what you are saying :-). > > > > >
>Let me try to give it a shot! You grabbed on to one > > >word
'secular' in Barua's sentence, but seemed to > > have > >
>ignored the gist of what he was trying to say. > > > >
> >From what I discerned, I felt Barua (Barua, correct > >
me > > >if I am mistaken) was trying to tell us that the >
> net > > > > > >is a democratic forum, where
members could voice > > >opinions for/against any topic and that
we should > > >avoid personal references. It shouldn't matter
if > > >someone is for/against GOI or Ulfa or something >
> else, > > >we should all have that voice to express,
and > > really > > >don't expect to be shouted down. That
you will > > agree > > >does us no good. That is what
will bring down the > > >STANDARDS of the net. > >
> > > >My observations are, by and large, we have been >
> very > > >accommdative of divergent views. Its difficult
to > > see > > >some of the most senior members bring out
their > > >rancour in an open forum. > > > >
> >My MO is very simple, when I read views from > > readers
- > > >I try very hard to read them at face value, without >
> >regard to what may or may not be their political > >
>beliefs off the net. Now, if were talking about > > >AANA/ASA,
those might come in play (I guess), but > > when > >
>talking about 'problems' in Assam, I really do not > > >look
for some ulterior motives. Some of those > > problems > >
>are real human problems, and I would like to give > > the >
> >utmost respect that they deserve. > > > > >
>I also try very hard not to take anything said > >
against > > > === message truncated
=== > > > > >
__________________________________ > Do you Yahoo!? > Read only
the mail you want - Yahoo! Mail SpamGuard. > http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail >
_______________________________________________ > Assam mailing
list > [email protected] > http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam > >
Mailing list FAQ: > http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html >
To unsubscribe or change options: > http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam > _______________________________________________ Assam
mailing list [email protected] http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam
Mailing
list FAQ: http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html To
unsubscribe or change options: http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam
|