C'da, I am little confused. And it leads me to wonder if it might be time for the NRA community to define what our role is vis-a-vis Assam and her problems (if at all there is a role).
When we discuss, identify problems, or even 'think' about possible solutions to these, it becomes pretty easy to label us as being condescending, 'looking down on the Assamese people' or 'assuming we are more intelligent', or 'speaking for all of Assam', etc. >*I* will never attempt to TELL, or LECTURE the people >of Assam what they should or must do..... >Neither I nor you are such luminaries, God's-gift-to->humanity, that they would be waiting with bated >breath to hear what I or you believe ... So, what is the role we need to play? Most of us have left Assam many moons ago - possibily never to return on a permanent basis. So, are we out of this picture? Is that your assessment? Should NRAs just shrug and sideline issues like the bombing in Dhemaji/Judge's field by Ulfa? Is there a role for us to condemn? Or when the military abused Manorama in Manipur - should we just remove ourselves from any discussion on the matter? Or should we just stick to innocous subjects like tea leaves, elephants, and flights to Gauhati - so that more than likely we will not be hurting someone's feelings. We all know that there are very intelligent people in Assam, and they know the problems better than we do. And no one is trying to dictate what they should or should not do. I feel that Barua was attempting to identify a set of problems, we should at least give him a hearing and discuss those issues. A sincere discussion on issues should not be such a big deal. Just because some of us have moved into this country permanently should not mean we have also divorced from Assam/India? does it? --Ram --- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Rajen: > > > I am glad you did not expect me to reply to this > post. Because, I > will be hard-pressed to do justice to it. But I felt > that I needed > to, in segments perhaps: > > > > > > >Sensing > >this, at one point I frankly suggested that let us > discuss offline so that > >we can sort out these differences outside the net > so that we donot have to > >take the entire through this gruelling excercise in > debate. > > > I did not wish to get into a private debate or > discussion, because it > is neither about you, nor about me. Besides neither > you nor I > represent ANY constituency of Assam. We discuss > these things in > public, hoping to raise awareness of the issues > among those who might > care to read. Great if we have some response, but > that happens so > rarely. > > > Anyway, why did YOU think I rejected the idea > flatly? What was your conclusion? > > > > >1) I have great > >convictions for the things I believe and at the > same time I am open for > >discussion. 2) I never take things personally. > > > I had no doubt of that. And I have always admired > that. Exactly the > reason I did not hesitate to be candid with my > comments and views. > But I do realize that even for the most secure and > open-minded, there > is a threshold, a boundary, beyond which one must > not venture, > without creating some backlash. I am afraid I > crossed that line with > my choice of words, which invited your anger. I > don't blame you for > it. It was MY fault for not exercising restraint. > > > >From the very beginning, I have been > >very upfront about what I believe and what I do not > believe. (You can check > >the records in the net and the netters be the > judge). > > >However I found that I > >could never found actually what you believe and > what you do not believe. > > > Absolutely unnecessary Rajen. It is not about you. > Same way, who > cares what MY beliefs are? People are too > pre-occupied with running a > life as it is. Neither I nor you are such > luminaries, > God's-gift-to-humanity, that they would be waiting > with bated breath > to hear what I or you believe. We are lucky if > anybody even reads > what we post. > > I am acutely aware of the fact that the sound of my > voice might charm > myself, but not many others. That is a sobering > realization. Has been > very helpful to me. > > But what I believe usually exude from every sentence > I write. People > who read them have a pretty darn good idea of were I > stand on the > issue under discussion. > That is NOT to suggest I go about TELLING or > LECTURING other people > on what to do. Like GoI, or GoA or ULFA or the > people of Assam. I > bring out the issues when I do, analyze them, and > hope I made some > persuasive arguments that others might accept, or at > least be > cognizant of. > > I am however always open to considering a specific > question on a > specific issue. > I try to answer as candidly and forthrightly as I > can, when I have an > answer. But unfortunately I DO NOT have an answer > to every issue > under the sun, or even Assam. Furthermore I respect > others' > intelligence not to LECTURE them. For example the > people of Assam, or > ULFA. > > For that reason, I do not attempt TELL those people > of Assam who agitate > to uphold their language/cultural/ethnic identity > are WRONG. That > they should not do that, because they have no right > to that, or > because others do not do so, or that it is > meaningless or any such > thing. It is an intangible, and cannot be measured > with an arbitrary > scale that I might hold dear. It is a GREY area. It > is very > subjective. No one needs any JUSTIFICATION to feel > that way. All it > requires is that IMAGINATION. > > That however is different from the rule of law, > something, if not > adhered to by society, it turns into various degrees > of anarchy, like > India is. That is a black and white issue. > > > > > >netters would know that I already said > >what believe about ULFA. I already told that ULFAs > are misguided brothers > >and that I donot beliecve in Soveregnity. > > > That is your right. I can't tell you not to believe > what you do. It > is just that I believe differently. I believe that a > group of people > which has imaginations of themselves as a distinct > nation, it is > their right to feel that way. It is their right to > regain their > sovereign, if it was denied them by others by force, > or coercion, or > trading or accident of history. > > I believe it is immature to tell them that they do > not deserve it, or > have no right to it, because someone traded it away, > or took it away > by military force. And even if it was consensually > given up with > conditions or understandings, if those conditions > were not fulfilled > or understandings breached, they have a right to > seek it back. > > > But the BOTTOM LINE is that, it is for those people > to decide what > they want, or what they can live with. In the > context of Assam, *I* > will never attempt to TELL, or LECTURE the people of > Assam what they > should or must do. It is for THEM to decide. If I > lived in Assam, *I* > would stand up for Assam's right. But I left, > voluntarily. I have no > right to TELL them anything. > > That is the single major difference in your and my > outlooks on these > matters, Rajen. > > > More later. > > c > > > > > > > At 1:13 AM -0600 2/5/05, Barua25 wrote: > >Chandan: > >As we can see there are major difference of opinion > (or === message truncated === __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com _______________________________________________ Assam mailing list [email protected] http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam Mailing list FAQ: http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html To unsubscribe or change options: http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam
