Ok, reading it again I think you're right, either way, however, the construction of the sentence looks odd. Shortening it up to use your wording below would likely be better:
The response to a POST request containing an Atom Entry Document SHOULD contain a Content-Location header that contains the same character-by-character value as the Location header. - James Sylvain Hellegouarch wrote: > James, > >> First minor nit: >> >> Section 8.1: >> >> When the POST request contains an Atom Entry Document, ... >> >> that should read "POST response" and not "POST request" > > I think you make a mistake. POST request is the correct wording here... > well it is my understanding. > > But if you are correct one should read, "a response to a POST request" not > "POST response". > > - Sylvain > >