>>>> If I really wanted a breathe mark after a grace note in another
>>>> voice (without grace notes), I would explicitly write
>>>>
>>>> ```
>>>> c1 \grace s8 \breathe
>>>> ```
>>>>
>>>> This works just fine, BTW.
>>> 
>>> Except that the note gets cut short in the MIDI.
>>
>> Indeed, I haven't checked MIDI.  Looks like a buglet to me.
> 
> Why would it be a bug if you tell LilyPond to cut short the note by
> one grace eighth, and that is exactly what LilyPond does?

Ah, you are talking about the value 8.  Please consider this just as a
dummy value that should be adapted to the actual needs – I only wanted
to talk about the order

```
<note> \grace XXX \breathe
```

to put the breathe mark between the grace stuff and the following
note.

>> Then we have to agree to disagree.  For me, the issue we are
>> discussing here is a bug.  In any case, we should probably improve
>> the documentation, mentioning potential problems with grace issues
>> for all affected grobs (and the current work-arounds, including
>> MIDI).
> 
> Sometimes we are talking about workarounds, sometimes we are talking
> about telling LilyPond what you want.

This is fine with me since I know that issue #34 (and probably related
grace music issues) is hard to fix – if at all.  The important thing
is documentation improvement.


    Werner

Reply via email to