Thanks Phyllis for your tests and GG for looking for.
I don't think you are misunderstanding.
I saw your video. I think it depends a bit from the video you are using
for the test: your clip is an animation. I can wrong. In your screencast
the histogram, in the Histogram Bezier, changes very, very, little.
Please, take a look at my screencast: https://streamable.com/3svwkd
As you can see, the histogram, in the Histogram Bezier, doesn't change
as in the Histogram.
More, you can see that when I enable the Histogram Bezier plugin a
little change occurs in the histogram of the View Scope. Mmh, very
strange. It is like if Histogram Bezier changes the Color Model of the
project, but I am guessing.
I am not saying it is "wrong", I think that it is really weird that
tools that perform the same function (draw an histogram) don't show the
same output, I would think.
IgorBeg
Il 27/09/2020 03:05, Phyllis Smith via Cin ha scritto:
IgorBeg,
GG thoroughly reviewed the Histogram code to understand how it works
so he could find any bugs. He says it is all working correctly as far
as he can tell.
But about the following:
When the Color Model format (in Settings->Format...) is set to RGB[A]
the histogram displayed on Histogram plugins is the same as on
Histogram
Bezier plugin.
If you change Color Model format from RGB[A] to YUV[A] the
histogram on
Histogram Bezier no changes, but on Histogram plugin and on View
Scopes
it changes. It is strange, I think.
In Histogram Bezier plugin the histogram doesn't change in the
differents color model.
we see in https://streamable.com/vr5srs that Histogram Bezier DOES
CHANGE between the formats of RGBA and YUVA (note that I have set the
slider all the way to Log in order to compare the same thing). You
have to watch the Histogram Bezier graph specifically, but you
definitely see it change. If I am misunderstanding the concern,
please let me know.
--
Cin mailing list
Cin@lists.cinelerra-gg.org
https://lists.cinelerra-gg.org/mailman/listinfo/cin
