Sorry Philip,

I realise that if taken literally, my email would imply that the decision
tree in your choosing which technologies to work with depends on whether or
not you could, as a result, wear stupid t-shirts with enthusiasm and a clear
conscience. Not the case, sorry for the ultra-dry humour. I was making light
of the W3C trivialising the value of its own specs while conflating
terminology (you'll notice they also say SVG and WOFF are now part of HTML5,
which is pure nonsense) in a way redolent of the most ignorant, obfuscatory,
hype-fed, marketing-minded idiots of the front-end world. Taking the mick.

Personally, I find HTML5's new input types (search, email, date, etc)
incredibly useful, especially for mobile devices where quick, rich input and
forms in general are often a nightmare. Seeing as they fall back to standard
type=text inputs on non-supporting browsers, I'm quite happy to use these
now; Video is absolutely fantastic, and I am already making great use of it
(with Flash fall-back) — again this is essential for modern mobile devices
and a great step forward in eschewing plugins. The simplified doctype with
definition omission and other trivial reductions in verbosity (charset
definition, script type omission) are nice but ultimately no great
game-changer; data-x attributes are useful, but again I didn't really need
their permission to use custom attributes; Local storage, while arguably a
JavaScript extension, falls under the banner, and I'm looking forward to
make serious use of this (once again, serious applications for mobile web).

So while I sympathise with your reticence as to the shallow-minded, naive,
obscurantist hype surrounding 'HTML5', the HTML5 spec has given me all sorts
of wonderful stuff I'm not about to dismiss…


Regards,
Barney Carroll

[email protected]
07594 506 381


On 19 January 2011 10:07, Philip Taylor (Webmaster, Ret'd) <
[email protected]> wrote:

>
>
> Barney Carroll wrote:
>
>> Philip,
>>
>> there is no reason at all to adopt it [HTML5]
>>
>> Stop being so cynical.
>>
>
> Cynical, Barney ?  No, just realistic.
>
>  What about these awesome badges/t-shirts?
>> http://www.w3.org/html/logo/
>>
>
> No comment needed.
>
> ? And the fact that CSS3 is now part of HTML5?
>
> What does "part of" mean in the context of two provisional
> specifications, each addressing a very different domain,
> and each being tackled by a different working group ?
>
> Philip Taylor
>
>
>
______________________________________________________________________
css-discuss [[email protected]]
http://www.css-discuss.org/mailman/listinfo/css-d
List wiki/FAQ -- http://css-discuss.incutio.com/
List policies -- http://css-discuss.org/policies.html
Supported by evolt.org -- http://www.evolt.org/help_support_evolt/

Reply via email to