On Wed, 11 Jan 2006 13:45:30 -0800, Tyler MacDonald wrote:

Hi Tyler

I do understand your point, but I think you need to re-think this.

> *whines* But this would break the functionality I was looking for
> in the first place: good automated QA being in a somewhat self-

So far so good.

> contained way. With SQLite2, the tests can run automatically
> against a database stored in a temporary file. I doubt CPAN testers

Still good.

> / ppm.activestate.com / etc are going to be setting DBI_DSN just to
> test this module. Without *some* DSN to test against, virtually no

But that's just it. They are precisely the target users who will install SQLite
to help testing, surely? I don't have it installed under Windows (search the
archives for why I don't trust it, or didn't way back when).

So, this means you have 2 target user groups:

o Serious testers, who, I assume, /will be/ prepared to install a testing
prerequisite

o Other users, who assume the above testers did their self-appointed :-) job, or
even if the testers did not test their (the users) platform, are prepared to
take the risk

> testing can happen at all, which means that a "PASS" on
> testers.cpan.org doesn't neccessarily mean the code works on that
> platform.

It's great to have testing, and more testing, but I wonder if you're not placing
too much emphasis on the /end-user/ level testing as against your own testing,
and other testers' tests.

Yes, I know you can't test various platforms, that's what the other testers are
for.

I have published a number of modules after testing them to my satisfaction, but
which do /not/ ship with complex testing, eg modules to be used against
databases, or to be used in CGI scripts.

In other words, you may have to accept that you'll be shipping code which has
not yet had an ideal (perfectionistic) level of testing...
--
Cheers
Ron Savage, [EMAIL PROTECTED] on 12/01/2006
http://savage.net.au/index.html
Let the record show: Microsoft is not an Australian company


Reply via email to