With two exceptions (neither of which have the websites trust bit set), all answers are now in from the April 2017 CA Communication. You can find links to the answers here: https://wiki.mozilla.org/CA/Communications#April_2017_Responses
Some highlights for the community's attention: * (Q1) It seems like all CAs are on track to implement domain validation via one of the Ten Blessed Methods by July 21st 2017. * (Q2) CAs are now required to increment the version number of their CP/CPS every year, which will make it much easier to notice CAs who are not regularly reviewing and revising their documentation. * (Q3) A few CAs might have difficulty meeting the June 1st deadline for CP/CPS in English. But of course, this may not be a problem unless their audit becomes due before they've got it done. * (Q5/Q6) There is some concern over the requirement to include the words "clean" or "qualified" in audit reports, particularly for ETSI audits. This is one for Kathleen to look at. * (Q8) All 60 CAs confirm they have ceased publicly-trusted SHA-1 SSL issuance :-) * (Q9) DocuSign (and perhaps T-Systems; it's not clear) are the only CAs of the 60 who say they have 3rd party RAs doing domain validation. * (Q11) A number of CAs haven't answered this or seem not to have quite understood the requirement. I sent some of them an email a week or two ago; I may need to send another. But still, it's a good starting collection of CAA identifiers. A surprisingly large number of CAs wish to use more than one domain name. DigiCert's comment is amusing: "digicert.com, although I may add misspellings of "Digicert" shortly. It happens a lot." * (Q13) Many CAs plan to stop issuing SHA-1 S/MIME by the end of this year. CAs without a firm date are: Comodo, GlobalSign, SECOM, TWCA, and Visa. A couple of these CAs hint that an industry deadline to stop would help their customers see the need to migrate. * (Q14) There is a surprising level of support for reducing certificate lifetimes to 13 months. Here's my quick analysis: YES 20 NO 21 MORE TIME 6 DV ONLY 4 N/A 4 UNKNOWN 4 The opposition group, though, contains many of the larger CAs (e.g. Comodo, Entrust, Symantec). Let's Encrypt is in favour, and GoDaddy is in the More Time camp. Most More Timers suggested March 2019 rather than 2018. A few CAs suggest reducing the lifetime for DV certs only. "Unknown" means they gave an answer but didn't actually indicate a position! Gerv _______________________________________________ dev-security-policy mailing list [email protected] https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-security-policy

