On 27 September 2012 11:01, "Ulrich Stärk" <u...@spielviel.de> wrote: > On Thu, September 27, 2012 11:24, Ross Gardler wrote: >> On 27 September 2012 10:17, "Ulrich Stärk" <u...@spielviel.de> wrote: >>> So an additional binary package including e.g. your Hibernate >>> integration >>> and a separate location in SVN/GIT where users can get the sources are >>> OK >>> IMO as long as both are not part of your official source distribution. >> >> This is not correct. The ASF does not maintain code under incompatible >> licenses. >> >> Ross >> > > Were did I say that? I'm talking about code depending on software with > incompatible licenses, such as a Hibernate integration.
If you didn't mean a separate SVN/Git repo on ASF hardware then you didn't say it and I misunderstood. The code in question, at http://code.google.com/a/apache-extras.org/p/camel-extra/ is under the GPL. The questions, as I read them, can be paraphrased as "can we develop GPL code using ASF infrastructure for everything else", from a community perspective I would say the answer is no (which you seem to agree with). I don't believe the question is about being legal able to use the code, the PMC is already using it. Ross
