> From: Jeff Trawick > Sent: Dienstag, 18. Juni 2013 15:32 > To: Apache HTTP Server Development List > Subject: Re: looking for luv > > On Tue, Jun 18, 2013 at 8:53 AM, Jim Jagielski <[email protected]> wrote: > I will be removing this backport request, but I'd ask sf to > actually address his concerns by actually working on the code > instead of just blocking it for whatever reason. > > Wow! Stefan raised a number of issues in STATUS which are spot-on > considerations when someone wants to merge a feature* from trunk to > a > stable branch. It is great that he took the time to dig through it and > comment on it, and it is hard to see your comments here as > > even remotely > pertinent to his concerns.
I agree. The original committer of the code should feel obliged to reply to those concerns and fix them after discussing the concerns if they turn out to be technically valid. It's not the duty of someone who raises concerns to fix stuff, he can if he likes, but it's not his duty. And raising a veto on a backport with valid technical reasons is IMHO no 'just blocking it for whatever reason'. Regards Rüdiger
