+1 On Mon, Nov 14, 2016 at 3:08 PM, Pavel Tupitsyn <ptupit...@apache.org> wrote:
> Igniters, > > We have set up Upsource code review tool at > http://reviews.ignite.apache.org/ > > I propose to evaluate it and see if it works for us. > > > * Why? > Current JIRA-based process is not very efficient. Anyone who have used a > review tool will probably agree: > > - No need to switch branches locally and interrupt your current work. You > can see the code in one click. > - All current reviews are easily accessible > - Multiple reviewers > - Much better discussions: comments are right in the code; each point can > be discussed and accepted separately > - Integrates with IDEA - open the diff in IDEA in one click, or see the > reviews there without opening the browser at all > > > * Why Upsource? > I've evaluated a bunch of tools (CodeCollaborator, ReviewBoard, > Phabricator, Crucible), > and Upsource looks like the best fit for us: > - PR-based code reviews. This is a major advantage: review for a PR can be > created in one click, and it updates automatically when you push more > commits (fix review issues) > - Good Java support and IDEA integration > - Good performance (our code base is big, and tools like Crucible really > struggle with it) > > > Thoughts and suggestions are welcome. > > Thanks, > > Pavel >
