+1 (binding)

Great job!

Things to improve, none of which I consider release-blocking:

- Missing Apache header in a few files, mostly XML and like files. It would
be great to make all that part of checkstyle.

- Examples produce shaded artifact, which bundles parts of Beam, Spark.
This bundling requires updates to license and notice files. But, this
shading process doesn't change what the main output JAR is, or what is
being uploaded to Nexus. I'm not sure what's the value of releasing binary
examples when nobody should link against them. I'd guess you'd want to
change this either to a Maven archetype or release source-only.

You can choose to address (or push back against) these for this release or
the next subsequent release. The first requires a new vote, so I wouldn't
recommend fixing it now, unless there are other issues. Depending on how
you want to address the second one, you may be able to fix it within Nexus,
without a new candidate/vote.

> If this is incorrect/less-preferable, please let me know so that I can
> > upload a new tarball.
>

No, leave this as is. It is perfect.

* * *

Overall, I'm thrilled to see this release going out. Thank you for the
great work.

Reply via email to