Le 10/04/2016 10:35, Jacques Le Roux a écrit :
Hi Jacopo, inline...

Le 21/03/2016 15:10, Jacopo Cappellato a écrit :
Jacques, thanks for raising this point that I think is worth of some
clarifications and enhancements to get the best out of the Jira reports.
 [...]
"Upcoming branch" should be used to mark all the issues that are
implemented in the trunk and not backported in the release branches

So, apart maybe some very specific cases, could we in others words say it 
should not be used by bug fixes?
About the very specific cases, I wonder when a bug fixes cannot be backported, 
notably to the last release branch.
I see only when a refactoring makes it too much troubles. Which also show that the refactoring was not well done: the bug should have been fixed during the refactoring[1].
Then it's maybe better to backport the refactoring AND the bug fixes on the 
refactoring...

Hi Jacopo,

I think a simple question with an example is better:

See https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/OFBIZ-6915 for upgrading to Tomcat 8.
It's a bug fix because there is a disputed vulnerability in Tomcat 7 
(CVE-2013-2185 tomcat-7.0.68-jasper.jar)
I set the fixed versions as,  Upcoming Branch, 15.12.01 because I committed in 
trunk and R15.12.

From what you said I should only set 15.12.01.
But then how users will know  (in release notes) that the next coming branch 
has been fixed also?

Thanks

Jacques

Reply via email to