On Sun, Sep 2, 2018 at 11:59 AM Dave Fisher <dave2w...@comcast.net> wrote:
> Hi Matteo - > > The BookKeeper bylaws are a problem in that the PMC Emeritus process is > not the Apache Way. Merit does not expire and numerous projects would be in > trouble if those were the wide rules. It may not cause trouble for a PMC in > the future. Not now as everything is good, but sooner or latter it may > become grounds for trouble in the community. This is a foundation wide > governance issue. IHMO - It is a bug in Whimsy. Which is why I brought it > where I did. As such keep in mind that Jim has a very valid point. He is a > Founder of the ASF and until this year had continually served as a Board > member and/or Officer every year. > > Let’s remove the clause from the Resolution. > +1 -- I'll update draft <snipped out an analysis of what is wrong with the BookKeeper bylaws. > Willing to discuss it with Sijie and Ivan on those lists.> > I didn't want to bring trouble also on BookKeeper :) -- Matteo Merli <mme...@apache.org>
