Didn't see the lips/mouth part; I'll try that! Speaking of which, I'm only going to post the icons I actually update from this point forward to make them easier to review, and keep numerous copies of the same images from cluttering Downloads folders.

-George Lambrou

On Oct 20, 09, at 8.13 pm, Eric Richie wrote:

On Oct 20, 2009, at 7:13 PM, Peter Hosey wrote:

On 2009-10-20, at 11:39, Evan Schoenberg wrote:
Peter, how do you feel about Voice 1 over Voice 5?

It's not clear (a wave emanating from a point? a single eye?), and as stated before, a shield doesn't make much sense for voice, which confers a privilege but no real powers.

+ isn't particularly expressive either, but it at least has history (and the IRC protocol itself) behind it, so a lot of users will recognize it as voice. For that reason and for not using a shield, I consider voice 5 the best voice icon so far.

What about something that might confer the idea of 'voice' in a less cryptic way? Maybe something along the lines of a pair of lips or a mouth, megaphone, speaker, microphone... Would that be a clearer direction to look?

-Eric

Reply via email to