On Monday, 7 May 2012 at 18:51:26 UTC, Sönke Ludwig wrote:
I think one of us (Jan) has something for better form handling
locally, not yet committed, and I would count that as something
that would still fit well into the core package. But in
general, I think the number of features should not grow too
much anymore - the core should contain all that is necessary
for _most_ applications and that with an interface that is as
comfortable as possible.
The main scope of modules, I would say, are higher level
features, features that are not as widely used or those which
provide alternatives to the functions in the core library.
Basic, common functionality, however, is always a candidate for
the core (OAuth(2) is on the way for example).
Another - quite banal - criterion could be if we would actually
use a feature ourselves, at least a bit; simply because if we
don't use it, we cannot test it without further time
investments and it could be unclear (to us) how well such a
component actually works (e.g. wrt. stable releases). Also, the
implementation/API style of a feature should match the rest of
the core library. The MySQL driver would be an example that
currently fails both criterions and thus is a module.
Maybe it would also be good to establish a defined procedure
such as: New features are implemented as modules first and
after a review it's decided if they should go in for the next
release. I don't have a real opinion on this yet and I'm
basically completely open for suggestions.
Sound good, now I'm just hoping that porting my forms stuff to
the core forms isn't going to be too hard :D.
Otherwise it seems you have a rough idea of what constitutes a
module and what is a feature, and that is a good start. I think
an informal review process for module -> feature promotion would
be good, since then the code can be available for use earlier.
Also, there is something to be said for making "official" vibe
modules, ones maintained, or at least, approved by the vibe team
and given slightly more prominence. This can keep the core system
small, but still allow the vibe team to provide more
functionality, especially if it is common functionality.
--
James Miller
