On 05/30/2013 09:23 AM, Maxim Fomin wrote:

> Note, that there is no problem with alising of slice and dynamic
> array, but there is problem with denying that dynamic array (according
> to spec) is a slice.

That gets back to your "banana" example. Slice and dynamic array is the same thing only because the spec says so. They do not have the same semantics of dynamic arrays as I know in programming.

They are not dynamic in the sense that they are on the heap. (Both your and my examples have trivially shown that.)

Further, they are not arrays in the sense that they own elements.

Therefore, calling this concept "dynamic array" is a historical accident. The spec may call it "dynamic array" but the spec cannot change what "dynamic array" means.

Ali

Reply via email to