On Saturday, 25 July 2015 at 12:09:34 UTC, Andrei Alexandrescu wrote:
However, making
it built-in feels really convenient in Rust:

- considerably less function declaration visual noise
- much better error messages: trying to use methods of T not defined by a trait will result in compile-time error even without instantiating the
template

Yah, building stuff in does have its advantages.

I feel it is not as much about "built-in vs library", but "generic vs templates" - somewhat deeper ideological difference that consequently calls for different tools. Metaprogramming with traits in Rust is inconvenient to the point of being almost impossible but generics have a very strong static API verification. In D you can get destroyed by flow of deeply nested error messages but the magic you can do with templates with minimal effort investment is beyond comparison.

Different values, different trade-offs.

Reply via email to