ToNyTeCh wrote:
Seriously, I wanna know. How many lines of compiler code does it take for
each (Walt should have the best handle on this, surely)? The LOC is one
parameter, but I don't want just that -- it just came to mind while
typing the overall question. The intricacy of the compiler is much more
important thatn the LOC. (Is D's compiler more intricate than C++'s?).
Any facts, feelings, guesses, whatever, are all welcomed in response. The
complexity in regard to usage would be a good thing to hear about from
users of all levels of experience (with D and other languages).
This is an interesting question. The difficulty in performing a direct
comparison (LOC or similar) is that DMD still has some implementation
gaps, so it will get bigger.
The parser for D is an order of magnitude simpler than C++, because it
is completely separated from the semantic pass. In fact, generally this
is true of the language: although there are some features that require a
lot of code, they are generally well-contained. Templates are much
simpler to implement than in C++, even though they are much more
powerful, because they are well-contained.
So generally, the compiler is less intricate.
But in terms of LOC, by the time everything in D is fully implemented, I
doubt that a D compiler will be significantly shorter than a C++ one.