On 2011-08-01 10:21, Jonathan M Davis wrote:
On Monday 01 August 2011 10:12:17 Jacob Carlborg wrote:
On 2011-08-01 03:56, Jonathan M Davis wrote:
If we do a hand-written lexer of D for Phobos, it really should be a
fairly direct port of the dmd front-end. It should be _somewhat_
D-ified as appropriate, (and the API should definitely be properly
range-based and all that), but the implementation needs to be fairly
close to dmd itself so that it's easy for someone to port changes and
fixes back and forth between the two. Otherwise, they're going to get
out of sync fairly easily. If we're not going to do a direct port, then
we might as well just do the template-based lexer generator that Andrei
and others would really like to see (which we should still do, but I
think that the hand-written lexer is nowhere near as valuable if it's
not a direct port of dmd's lexer).

In the long run I hope that this won't be necessary, I'm hoping that DMD
will use the lexer from Phobos.

Also, I see _zero_ value in making it support D1. If it's for D2's
standard library, then what's the point of it lexing D1? That just
complicates the lexer for what is essentially a legacy product. And
given that the differences between D1 and D2 in dmd's lexer are covered
with #ifdefs, it would be rather complicated to try and do a direct
port which covers both D1 and D2. It would probably be easier if the
two were completely separate.

As for what I've done so far, I'd have to go look. I haven't touched it
in a couple of months, I expect. There has been a lot of other stuff
that I've needed to do, and Andrei was trying to discourage such an
implementation the last time that I brought it up. So, I haven't
exactly been in a rush to get it done. I'd like to do it, but I've been
rather busy.

In this case I really don't think that you should listen to Andrei.

Well, when I have multiple things on my plate, and Andrei has a major
disagreement with one, I'm less likely to focus on that one. It's also one
which takes quite a bit of time and focus, whereas there is other stuff which I
can do in smaller chunks of time without needing as much focus. So, I haven't
worked on it as much. I should probably remedy that, but there's quite a lot
that I've been trying to get done.

So, yes. I intend to do it in spite of Andrei's opinion on the matter, but
lately I've been focusing on other stuff which needs doing.

- Jonathan M Davis

Fair enough.

--
/Jacob Carlborg

Reply via email to