On Sunday, August 21, 2011 20:36:55 bearophile wrote: > Andrei Alexandrescu: > > Yah, it's pretty neat, and very much in the spirit of D. I'd missed it. > > Thank you Andrei. This problem is know as "Dangling else problem". When a > bug receives a name, you know it's common enough. > > This is one of the about one dozen of tiny/small breaking changes I'd like > for D2. I'd like to speed up a little this very slow "presentation" I am > doing of them, because it's taking a very long time (on the other hand this > specific enhancement request did receive an answer).
Except that it's not a bug. It's an issue that crops up in grammars for programming languages. There is classic solution to the problem which D follows. So, there is no ambiguity, and there is no bug. It's very much by design. Bugs caused by mis-handling if statements related to dangling elses are _very_ rare in C-based languages. I really think that the only reason that you're running into this at all is because you've been translating python code to D without adding braces. - Jonathan M Davis
