On 08.12.2011 05:52, bcs wrote:
On 12/07/2011 08:49 AM, Alex Rønne Petersen wrote:
I really do not see the value in allowing such syntax in the first
place. I've been told that one argument was that generated code might
use it, but I have no idea why it would be needed. Furthermore, this
operator makes it very hard to introduce Python-style tuples in the
language.
IIRC the generated code argument was actually made with regards to the
compiler doing internal rewriting of the AST. If I'm remembering
correctly, this make it even weaker as, at that point, there is no
reason that the form of the AST need match the syntax.
Worth noting that the comma operator inside the compiler is not the same
as the one in the language. It supports declarations, in a way that D
doesn't. You can't write this in normal D, for example:
(int x; , x = 2);
But that's what the compiler does internally.
The "compiler uses it internally" argument isn't valid at all.