At 10/18/01 7:22 AM, Michael J. Masin wrote:

>>Wouldn't it be even more convenient to provide all this in a pre-configured
>>link so that the client just needs to click it instead of clicking and
>>typing/pasting two words in two input fields?
>
>Amen! So many try to key in the information rather than cut/paste (and 
>never get it right.)

Which brings me to another nit-pick: a lot of people don't understand 
case-sensitivity. This could be fixed by using numbers only as the 
approval key, rather than strings of letters like "dhYaDSmM". When 
generating initial default passwords, etc., I like to use numbers-only 
with even 1 and 0 removed (to prevent confusion with "L" and "o").

An eight-digit numbers-only string using digits 2-9 still gives you 16.7 
million possible codes, and it's impossible for a user to misinterpret or 
mistype. (OK, I guess they could have Num Lock off, but at least they'll 
probably figure it out, whereas people who don't understand 
case-sensitivity won't.)

But Kai Schaetzl's suggestion (a short URL eliminating the need to retype 
the key entirely) would be even better than all this. It could just take 
you to a page that has "Approve" and "Deny" buttons (as well as the WHOIS 
comparator, etc.). It couldn't be that hard to set up a system to deal 
with URLs like:

  http://approve.opensrs.org/4578664432783784

And that eliminates all of these problems completely.

--
Robert L Mathews, Tiger Technologies

Put an animated US flag on your Windows desktop: http://deskflag.com/

Reply via email to