garym wrote: 
> I ran the test on two players (a transporter and a boom). Both connected
> via eithernet to gigabit switch with Cat6.
> 500kbps and less - 100%
> 1000 kbps - about 75%
> 1500 kbps - about 49%
> 2000 kbps - about 40%
> 
> 


Those numbers are more-or-less the same as I'm seeing. You really think
your network chacteristics just happen by chance to be the same as
mine?

I know enough about networking/TCP to say that a UDP test can be
misleading or even irrelevant. What is most likely happening is that at
1Mbps, when blasting UDP, there are buffer overflow problems on the SB
itself that are the cause of the loss (not the network).

But, given that music is streamed over TCP, you'd need to measure TCP
performance to get a sense for what that actual data transfer rate can
be in practice. A UDP test measures something totally different...

And seeing even 10% packet loss generally kills TCP perforance. But I'm
able to stream flac files with no apparent problems, which suggests that
the numbers Network Test are throwing out are bogus.

garym wrote: 
> 
> This said, even 24/96 hires files play just fine on both with no
> dropouts. I'm no expert on network TCP transmissions but I suspect that
> even with packet loss as high as 50% (the 1500 kbps test) the buffer
> solves any problem from appearing (at least on my end).
> 
> http://wiki.slimdevices.com/index.php/Diagnosing_Performance_Issues#Network_Performance
> 
> edit:  listening now to a 24/96 album and transporter is reporting kbps
> of 2870 of flac file that is playing.   No dropouts or rebuffering. next
> song is 3188 kbps and also plays OK)

There is no way you could stream at 3168 kbps if the numbers Network
Test were showing where accurate. The math doesn't add up.

Thanks for running the tests!


------------------------------------------------------------------------
narten's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=62152
View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=100536

_______________________________________________
discuss mailing list
discuss@lists.slimdevices.com
http://lists.slimdevices.com/mailman/listinfo/discuss

Reply via email to