In message <05d573029041928upimssmtpus...@email.msn.com> "Alan E Hutley" 
writes: 

> We publish the UK EMC Journal and would like to publish some of the Q&As
> that appear here.   Does anyone out there have a problem with this.   Your
> comments would be welcomed.   We want to build up a list of FAQs which will
> also be published on our web site.

Alan,

As you know, I have included your Q&A FAQs (in the sense of a set of 
specific frequently-asked questions and their answers) in the FAQ (in the 
sense of a listing of material and sources) which I update each month for 
the s.e.e.c (sci.engr.electrical.compliance) newsgroup.  

I have been for many months sending a short announcement of the monthly 
update to EMC-PSTC (and also, for that matter, to TREG), which seems to 
have met with general approval, or at least nobody has ever expressed 
disapproval.  What I have not done, nor would I think appropriate, is to 
mail the lengthy FAQ itself to the mailing list.

I think the point of mailing lists like EMC-PSTC is that they are for 
questions and discussions on specific topics as they arise, not for 
posting of general material, however valuable.  Short pointers to the 
availability (elsewhere) of such material is useful, or at least not 
objectionable.  Occasionally there might be a specific announcement from 
someone in the know of a new piece of information, but I would have 
thought regular mailings of quasi-tutorial material not appropriate.

The alternative, of course, is to start your own mailing list for 
dissemination of whatever material you choose, in which case I am sure 
participants in EMC-PSTC would not object to an announcement of your 
mailing list so they can subscribe if they choose.

Hope you (and other readers) won't mind a slightly different query, Alan, 
which is whether you wish your Q&A FAQs to continue to appear in the 
s.e.e.c FAQ, and if so whether you can provide updates.  (The s.e.e.c FAQ 
is available at http://world.std.com/~techbook/compliance_faq.html) 

Regards to all,

Bill.

-- 
Bill Lyons - b...@lyons.demon.co.uk / w.ly...@ieee.org
             (maintainer of the s.e.e.c FAQ)

Reply via email to