On 03/24/2016 06:24 PM, Robert J. Hansen wrote:
1. Take the semantic that you proposed for the wax seal (greyed out,
"lit" for positive integrity, broken for integrity failure) and extend
it to the other two icons.
I don't like this as applied to the envelope/postcard icon. That one, I
think the two different icons make it immediately clear which privacy
regime is in effect -- "like a postcard" or "like an envelope".
One of the reasons for my suggestion is that I think this will be
challenging for the icon artist to represent with sufficient distinction
to make it immediately obvious to the user. I think we also have to keep
in mind the way that tbird uses the envelope icon to represent an S/MIME
message. That said, if we get good icons for this, I think the semantic
(postcard vs. envelope) is a good one.
I also think the Guy Fawkes mask is needed, but you're right, it
shouldn't appear for all unauthenticated email. It should appear for
bad signatures. A passport for a verified sender, a grayed-out passport
for an unknown sender, a Guy Fawkes mask for a "this signature is bad
and someone may be playing games with you". It would be the analogue to
the seal, grayed-out seal, and broken seal iconography for signatures;
passport, grayed-out passport, Guy Fawkes mask.
I think this is much better.
2. Consider placement for these icons in a manner similar to the way
tbird handles S/MIME currently. I don't need a separate bar for this
feature, and don't want to take up precious screen real estate for it.
That would be ideal, yes.
Awesome! And thanks for the response. :)
Doug
_______________________________________________
enigmail-users mailing list
[email protected]
To unsubscribe or make changes to your subscription click here:
https://admin.hostpoint.ch/mailman/listinfo/enigmail-users_enigmail.net
