"Kotsinadelis, Peter (Peter)" wrote:
> 
> One last comment, if you look at some of the examples of bad bokeh note the
> jagged lines follow the shape of the aperture.  A more hexagonal shape
> produces less smooth out of focus areas than a rounder aperture.  Bottom
> line is that one should buy  good lenses with round apertures.
> 

Shape (or number of blades) of the aperture is only part of the game.
I sure don't buy my lenses because of good bokeh, but I occasionally 
notice it in my pictures. 

E.g. if I compare the 200/2.8 L and 80-200/2.8 L at 200mm.
Both lenses have 8 aperture blades, the shape of the aperture should 
therefor be similar. Nevertheless, the 80-200 renders out of focus 
highlights not as smooth as the prime. The difference is, that the
circls of confusion are more evenly illuminated with the prime, while
the zoom is quite uneven, if my memory serves me right it's even a 
little darker in the center than at the edges. Last year I have taken
one frame with it, where it really jumped out on me and where I thought:
Ouch! This would have come out much better with the 200/2.8 prime. 
Ok, no big deal, I have taken a lot of pictures with it where it really 
shines, so I certainly don't think about getting rid of it because of 
"bad bokeh". Its sharpness and contrast is quite good, that's what 
counts the most for me too.

Thomas Bantel
*
****
*******
***********************************************************
*  For list instructions, including unsubscribe, see:
*    http://www.a1.nl/phomepag/markerink/eos_list.htm
***********************************************************

Reply via email to