I agree as well. I usually only have one thing to say every so often. As the 
overlord says below questioning the rules or the status-quo is perceived by a 
bunch on here that it is a bad thing. But think how our country would be if we 
didn't question the rules of the British rules and taxation. (Sorry to the 
British fans here - hehe) I am not one to just believe the rules are perfect 
and not question them. No one is infallible , not the rule creators, Ray or 
anyone else. Opinion is a fine edged blade and should be welcomed by any that 
want to give it. Pointing out the issues, and getting the kind of treatment I 
saw from some of you reminds me of some of the black listing, and other 
nonsense that occurred during the cold war. That is why we have a system that 
allows for continual improvement. For those of you in the IT world and know 
about ITIL think of the service life cycle and how something should be always 
looked at during operation. Same thing applies here. Rules can be improved, and 
just because you state them and blast them doesn't make them right. 


On the other hand some rules do make sense, I think there should be a rule that 
says that silly people should not become mad at a fellow fan for being himself. 
Remember freedom of speech and all that fun stuff. If you don't want to answer 
his question about Ben 10 - then be the better person as the Overlord mentions 
and ignore him. I did on some of the queries. And then I would read the retorts 
and some of the responses. And all I kept thinking was that I was talking to a 
10 year old but not for Parks, but for the responses. If this gets me kicked 
off the list for putting my opinion then it is as it is. I will probably just 
ignore type of responses if they flare me and continue on my day. I enjoy all 
conversation and despair when I see those that limit it in any fashion. 


Ed 




Date: Sat, 21 Apr 2012 04:30:18 -0400 
Subject: Re: Feistfans-l list rules 20-April-2012 - Goodbye and Good night! 
From: [email protected] 
To: [email protected]; [email protected] 

I may get some flack for this, but I personally enjoyed most of his/her (sorry 
for the guessing) posts. Yes rules were broken and no one will debt that. And 
they are, for the most part, important rules that have a valid reason for 
existing. But, I feel that questioning rules should never be discouraged and 
helps keep said rules evolving as our little world changes. 
And maybe I'm naive, but after the first week of everyone putting in their two 
cents and tearing him apart for questioning and challenging the list to show 
WHY the rules are in place, he participated in discussions. I do not feel as if 
he was being disingenuous about wanting to be involved in this group. 
You may call him a troll and write him off, your choice. But I think he made a 
few good points about some of you. Several times I felt like I was in 4th grade 
and the tattletales were all running to teacher about how Parks laughed at your 
haircut. This is not school either ignore him, petition his removal or be 
silent, your pointing out that he violated article 6 of subsection A adds 
nothing but gasoline to a very small spark. And I'd rather have someone who 
might question the rules or make the occasional off topic comment than someone 
who seems to only care about pointing out how wrong another is. 
Just my 2 cents. 

On Apr 20, 2012 8:22 PM, "Parks White" < [email protected] > wrote: 


As tiresome as I have clearly been to many on the fanlist I welcome the 
collective cheer when I announce that I too have tired of the tedium and the 
carefully constructed rules and enforcement tactics. 

I will unsubscribe from the fanlist forthwith. 
0 
Thanks to REF, the hosts and those who participate in discussions, however the 
Lurkers and classroom monitors offer little value in my opinion. 

Best wishes. 

Ka kite ano 

Parks3 

Sent from my iPad 

On 21/04/2012, at 12:02 PM, "Noah P. Melnick" < [email protected] > wrote: 

> I am from the school of thought that says the best counter to bad speech is 
> more speech, but I have to confess Parks your continued questioning of the 
> rules (and other breaches of them) is actually making me question that 
> proposition. This is a graciously hosted private public forum in which we're 
> all in effect guests. Guests don't usually complain so much about how their 
> hosts ask them to behave. They usually just accept it and say thank you. 
> 
> On Apr 20, 2012, at 7:03 PM, Parks White < [email protected] > wrote: 
> 
>> Children as young as 10!?...Ray has stated both he and his publisher do not 
>> publish books for young adults, and by implication younger children. why 
>> would a fan list allow minors to participate in a mail list like this? are 
>> there not risks for children including meeting unsavory types ( present 
>> company excluded) greater on a fan list. I would never let my child 
>> subscribe until at he is at least 16 to be safe. having 10 year olds will 
>> certainly limit conversations even further than the list of forbidden 
>> topics... 
>> 
>> Sent from my iPad 
>> 
>> On 21/04/2012, at 1:35 AM, John < [email protected] > wrote: 
>> 
>>> With all the issues of rules that have recently occurred, I thought it 
>>> prudent to have one email with the relevant links 
>>> 
>>> Information fro Newbies 
>>> < http://www.crydee.com/raymond-feist/mailing-list/information-for-newbies 
>>>> 
>>> 
>>> Feistfans-l Mailing List User Guide 
>>> < http://www.crydee.com/raymond-feist/faq/feistfans-l-mailing-list-user-gu 
>>> ide> 
>>> 
>>> Now save this email somewhere you can easily find it again. 
>>> 
>>> 
>>> And remember this list is frequented by members of all ages, and has as low 
>>> as 10 ! So make sure what you post is suitable for all ages. 
>>> -- 
>>> John 
>>> 
>>> The Official Raymond E Feist Website 
>>> http://www.crydee.com/ 
>>> 
>>> Books to read, and shelves to fill, 
>>> Ray's great books, just fit the bill. 
>>> 
>>> 
>>> 
>>> 
>>> 
>> 
>> 
> 
> 




Reply via email to