Short version: Grow up. Both sides.

Long version....

Another issue is that those of us who do jump in to offer correction
can forget that no matter how many times we've seen the problem and
tried to correct it, for the newbie on the list it's their first time
making that particular mistake. I have seen replies that are snarkier
than necessary (heck, I've written some of those at times, though
generally I try to avoid it), and that doesn't help - we could all do
a little better on that front.

Bottom line is that we expect (or should expect) that not everyone
knows the rules, or even agrees with them. We don't (and shouldn't)
expect a long, drawn-out public debate every time someone new is
introduced to the rules for the first time. You may not agree with
them, and asking for clarification is one thing -- but arguing that
the rules are bad, antiquated, or shouldn't apply to any particular
person is just incredibly annoying -- particularly when you're seeing
it for the hundredth time. Any discussion of the rules that's centered
around "*I* don't like that!" is destined to go badly.

Does that mean something's wrong with the rules, that so many people
complain about them? I don't think so -- many MORE people respect them
(well, except perhaps the off-topic rules) and have little or no
problem following them, and don't throw a fit if someone gently
reminds them when they forget. The reasons for the rules we have are
still valid even if some are not as commonplace as they once were --
though if anything, spoiler warnings in particular are more valid than
ever, as Ray writes more books that could be spoiled.

Reply via email to