Except when people do do hat and the badgering continues anyways. 

Sent from my iPhone

On Apr 22, 2012, at 8:16 AM, David Marcus <[email protected]> wrote:

> Fact is it s a mailing list for Mr. Feist's books that is governed by rules 
> established by Mr. Feist, the owner of the list, and developed over many 
> years to avoid unpleasantness.  I am constantly amazed at the inability of 
> many visitors who come to this list to follow the rules.  I am even more 
> amazed by the reaction of certain individuals when they are corrected for 
> having violated the rules and asked not to do so again.  We could probably 
> cut down traffic on the list by 25% if when someone broke a rule and was 
> corrected, the response was mature and gracious...something on the order of 
> "I'm sorry...I didn't realize.  I won't do that again."
> 
> Best,
> David
> 
> On Apr 22, 2012, at 8:07 AM, Jeff C Goodhall wrote:
> 
>> FACT is YOU ALL need to get a fecking life or work harder! It's a mailing 
>> list for books, end of.
>> ----- Original Message -----
>> From: Ray Chiang
>> To: feistfans-l
>> Sent: Saturday, April 21, 2012 7:18 PM
>> Subject: Re: Feistfans-l list rules 20-April-2012 - Goodbye and Good night!
>> 
>> On 4/21/2012 9:16 AM, John Buttimer wrote:
>>> 
>>> Well said well said!
>>> 
>>> On Apr 21, 2012, at 8:34 AM, [email protected] wrote:
>>> 
>>>> 
>>>> I agree as well. I usually only have one thing to say every so often. As 
>>>> the overlord says below questioning the rules or the status-quo is 
>>>> perceived by a bunch on here that it is a bad thing. But think how our 
>>>> country would be if we didn't question the rules of the British rules and 
>>>> taxation. (Sorry to the British fans here - hehe) I am not one to just 
>>>> believe the rules are perfect and not question them. No one is infallible, 
>>>> not the rule creators, Ray or anyone else. Opinion is a fine edged blade 
>>>> and should be welcomed by any that want to give it. Pointing out the 
>>>> issues, and getting the kind of treatment I saw from some of you reminds 
>>>> me of some of the black listing, and other nonsense that occurred during 
>>>> the cold war. That is why we have a system that allows for continual 
>>>> improvement. For those of you in the IT world and know about ITIL think of 
>>>> the service life cycle and how something should be always looked at during 
>>>> operation.  Same thing applies here. Rules can be improved, and just 
>>>> because you state them and blast them doesn't make them right.
>> 
>> Getting up on your soapbox, while cathartic, is mostly useless on a mailing 
>> list.  Comparing members of this list to McCarthyists and elementary 
>> schoolers, is doubly counterproductive.  Analogies are useful, but are not 
>> particularly useful when dealing with specifics (like, say rules for the 
>> FEISTFANS-L mailing list).
>> 
>> If you want to effect change, *propose* something.  If you think the spoiler 
>> police is too heavy handed, volunteer to do it yourself for a while and 
>> bring a gentler hand.  If you don't like the spoiler rule, propose that we 
>> suspend it for a while (one month, six months, etc.) and see if anyone gets 
>> offended during that time.
>> 
>> -Ray
>> 
> 

Reply via email to