As a former live (as opposed to formerly-living) stage performer, there's a simple answer for the necessity I feel for attending live CONCERT events:
 
The excitement, the energy, the palpable anticipation and constant shared experience of a few hundred to a couple thousand fellow attendees sitting with you -- that community of (not to completely bludgeon the point) like-minded hungry humanity being fed along side you.
 
And mind you, of course, there are always annoying exceptions: the coughing, the matinee crowds who might be there simply in the hopes that a loud noise will reassure them that they're still alive, those that have attended not because they wish to but because they feel they 'have' to...yeah, sure, exceptions.   But given the choice of sitting in my comfortable living room with my great sound system to hear a canned (or even 'live' canned) CD recording versus dressing up to sit in a somewhat-less body-rewarding situation but: BUT: to have that communal experience with a great orchestra under a great conductor in a great hall with great acoustics:
 
Yeah.   Easy choice.
 
I'm somewhat less energetic in my preference for live theatrical experiences over a great DVD at home with sound cranked; I really draw a distinction between the forms.   A play is not a film is not tv is not a musical is not the same.   Apples/orangutans.   I find seeing a filmed play -- a strictly filmed play -- on TV a terrific bore.   A good film adaptation of the same play would be fine at home; perhaps preferable in a big-screen theatre if the jerks around me stop talking and unwrapping the candies and....
 
But music?   Hands-down: Live.   Exciting. 
 
Best, 
 
Les
    
 
Les Marsden
Founding Music Director and Conductor,
The Mariposa Symphony Orchestra
Music and Mariposa?  Ahhhhh, Paradise!!!
 
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Saturday, January 29, 2005 10:12 AM
Subject: Re: [Finale] Garritan and other stuff

At 12:56 PM 1/29/05 -0500, Christopher Smith wrote:
>When it comes down to it, why should ANYONE go to a live show?

Ain't that the truth. :)

I'm one of those who prefers to listen to recordings or watch films. To me,
live performances are the rehearsals for the recordings (as long as the
recordings aren't flattened by so many takes as to remove the musical
interest). There are good moments now & then in live performances, but they
tend to be extra-musical.

But recordings have been thrilling & rewarding and changed my life. In 45
years of going to concerts, I've never been excited or moved in the same
way. Of course, my musical experiences came from recordings, so maybe
that's why.

Improvisatory artforms are another matter -- that's where the composition
happens in real time. But if you're reading from a score or a script, give
me a recording any day!

Dennis

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
Finale@shsu.edu
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to