From: Brian Lloyd <[email protected]>
Date: Thu, 2 Jun 2011   Time: 10:43:52

Ah, thank you for providing me with a soapbox for a pet peeve of mine. :-)

Your chart is quite good. Thank you. Regardless, I would suggest losing
the "dial frequencies" altogether. The problem is, dial-frequency is a
holdover from days gone by when we had hardware terminal units (TUs) for
RTTY. Dial frequency is something that needs to be calculated and only
serves to confuse people if provided. They think that the set the dial on
their radio to the published "dial frequency" and they will be on-frequency.
Not so. I think we need to emphasize that dial frequency must be
*calculated* based on subcarrier frequency and desired emission
frequency.


<snip>

Brian

I agree with you entirely. It's only the emitted frequency that matters -- it doesn't matter how it is generated. I even said as much in the 30MDG reflector when I first questioned the tabular listing:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
To me it is not clear from the "Band
Plan NOT official" what these frequencies actually represent. Are they
radiated frequencies, or are they USB dial frequencies, or are they a
mixture of both? (I suspect the CW allocations are radiated frequencies,
whereas the digital mode allocations are USB dial frequencies. Or is
this too simple a distinction?)
It's the transmitted frequency that matters, not the
means of generating it.
That said, can the band plan be reworked so that it only specifies
transmitted frequencies? Then everyone will know exactly where we stand.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Then people responded on and off-list saying they *must* have the dial frequency. That's all they understand. It shouldn't be like that, but that's how it is.

So I decided to take the middle route, and specified both dial frequency and emitted frequency. However, to keep everyone happy, I introduced the (as yet unexplained) color coding on the chart. The yellow boxes indicate ranges of emitted frequencies, with no dial frequencies, that people can slide up and down with fldigi or whatever. The gray boxes, with associated dial frequencies, are (more-or-less) "fixed" frequencies of operation, and the dial frequency is what you use with the (usually) only software package available that generates the signal.

In the case of AX.25, most people seem to use the KAM tones, so that is what I used here in specifying the dial frequency. At least one website tells you, in tortuous detail, how to set the dial frequency if you are using a different TNC and/or sideband. This shouldn't be necessary, but some people need it -- I'm totally comfortable with that, if that is what we need to do to make sure people transmit in the right place.

--
73
Ian, G3NRW

The 30m Band Utilization Chart:
  http://homepage.ntlworld.com/wadei/30m_band_utilization.htm


































_______________________________________________
FlexRadio Systems Mailing List
[email protected]
http://mail.flex-radio.biz/mailman/listinfo/flexradio_flex-radio.biz
Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/flexradio%40flex-radio.biz/
Knowledge Base: http://kc.flexradio.com/  Homepage: http://www.flexradio.com/

Reply via email to