On Fri, Jun 3, 2011 at 1:11 AM, Ian Wade G3NRW <[email protected]> wrote:

> Brian
>
> I agree with you entirely. It's only the emitted frequency that matters --
> it doesn't matter how it is generated. I even said as much in the 30MDG
> reflector when I first questioned the tabular listing:
>

That is reality.

Then people responded on and off-list saying they *must* have the dial
> frequency. That's all they understand. It shouldn't be like that, but that's
> how it is.
>

That is just flat-out not true. We are not born to understand "dial
frequency" in our DNA. We learn how to use these radios and we relearn when
something changes. Well, guess what, something has changed. People need to
relearn. Welcome to the world of amateur radio, a technical hobby. I know,
learning is hard. They have already learned to use dial frequency back in
the days of hardware TUs so why should they relearn? (Heck, why aren't we
still using spark and model 15 teleprinters?) Now we have software that does
the work but requires us to set both VFO and subcarrier frequency. There is
no standardization on this so in order to get on the same frequency for a
QSO, different people are going to have different dial frequencies.
*THAT*is reality.

What audio subcarrier do we use? I happen to use 1500 Hz with PowerSDR but
1000 Hz with the K2. 1000 Hz matches the filter better. My dial frequencies
are different, period, end-of-report. Giving people dial frequencies
actually fosters more problems, especially with new people who use modern
sound-card-based terminal units (or whatever you want to call it).


>
> So I decided to take the middle route, and specified both dial frequency
> and emitted frequency.


Emitted frequency center is absolutely necessary. And as long as you are
using dial frequency too, would you put in the dial frequency for my 5000
(-1500 Hz offset), my K2 (-1000 Hz offset), and I guess the "standard" for
RTTY (+2125 Hz offset). We should have no problem coming up with several
more "standard" dial frequencies to keep everyone happy!


> However, to keep everyone happy, I introduced the (as yet unexplained)
> color coding on the chart. The yellow boxes indicate ranges of emitted
> frequencies, with no dial frequencies, that people can slide up and down
> with fldigi or whatever. The gray boxes, with associated dial frequencies,
> are (more-or-less) "fixed" frequencies of operation, and the dial frequency
> is what you use with the (usually) only software package available that
> generates the signal.
>

That does make a lot of sense.


>
> In the case of AX.25, most people seem to use the KAM tones, so that is
> what I used here in specifying the dial frequency. At least one website
> tells you, in tortuous detail, how to set the dial frequency if you are
> using a different TNC and/or sideband. This shouldn't be necessary, but some
> people need it -- I'm totally comfortable with that, if that is what we need
> to do to make sure people transmit in the right place.
>

But that is what should happen. People need to figure out their own "dial
frequency" based on their configuration. The only standard is "what is the
frequency of my emission."

-- 
Brian Lloyd, WB6RQN/J79BPL
3191 Western Dr.
Cameron Park, CA 95682
[email protected]
+1.767.617.1365 (Dominica)
+1.931.492.6776 (USA)
(+1.931.4.WB6RQN)
_______________________________________________
FlexRadio Systems Mailing List
[email protected]
http://mail.flex-radio.biz/mailman/listinfo/flexradio_flex-radio.biz
Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/flexradio%40flex-radio.biz/
Knowledge Base: http://kc.flexradio.com/  Homepage: http://www.flexradio.com/

Reply via email to