Exception() base doesn't include the method, but the properties ($e->line, and $e->file I *believe*, check the docs) are protected so you should be able to implement your own setFile() and setLine() methods from the extended Zend_Exception.
John -- John Coggeshall Team Lead NA Pro. Services Zend Technologies > -----Original Message----- > From: Bill Karwin [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: Monday, December 18, 2006 12:57 PM > Cc: Aleksey V. Zapparov; Zend Framework General > Subject: Re: [fw-general] Re: Do we really need Zend::exception()? > > Okay I just tried this: > > <?php > function testException() > { > require_once 'Zend.php'; > try { > $x = Zend::exception('Zend_Exception', 'boo!'); > throw $x; > } catch (Zend_Exception $e) { > echo "{$e->getMessage()}\n"; > echo "file: {$e->getFile()}\n"; > echo "line: {$e->getLine()}\n"; > echo "trace: {$e->getTraceAsString()}\n"; > } > } > > testException(); > ?> > > > The output is: > > -------- > boo! > file: C:\zf\library\Zend.php > line: 229 > trace: #0 C:\zf\library\testex.php(6): > Zend::exception('Zend_Exception', > 'boo!') > #1 C:\zf\library\testex.php(16): testException() > #2 {main} > -------- > > You're right, it isn't the line where it's thrown. It > reports the file and line where the exception class is > instantiated, inside the > Zend::exception() function. But the stack trace shows where the > Zend::exception() function was called. > > I changed the it to the more traditional: > > throw new Zend_Exception('boo!'); > > And the output changed to this: > > -------- > boo! > file: C:\zf\library\testex.php > line: 8 > trace: #0 C:\zf\library\testex.php(15): testException() > #1 {main} > -------- > > Regarding John's suggestion: the Exception class has no methods > setFile() or setLine(). > > Regards, > Bill Karwin > > > Darby Felton wrote: > > Hi all, > > > > Zend::exception() only returns an exception; it does not currently > > throw an exception, by design, to avoid such obfuscation: > > > > throw Zend::exception('SomeException', 'Some Message'); > > > > Best regards, > > Darby > > > > Bill Karwin wrote: > > > >> Nico Edtinger wrote: > >> > >>> With Zend::exception() we avoid loading all those > exception classes > >>> that are only needed if an error occurs, which should be > an exception. > >>> So instead of loading these files or at least stat()ing > it with an > >>> opcode cache we waste some lines in a file that's loaded anyway. > >>> That has nothing to do with bugs in any class. > >>> > >> But it's a good point that this method causes stack traces > to become > >> obfuscated. It reports the __FILE__ and __LINE__ of the > exception as > >> occurring in Zend::exception, because that's where the > exception is > >> actually thrown. > >> > >> Regards, > >> Bill Karwin > >> > >> > >> > > > > > > >