Eli, I think the intent from the email was to just vote on this thread, which I agree with. Discussions should be done in a separate threads. Hopefully we can all stick to just voting!
thanks mahadev On Wed, May 4, 2011 at 5:22 PM, Eli Collins <e...@cloudera.com> wrote: > Good suggestion, it would be helpful to hash out the issues around > compatibility, feature branches, version numbers, how to contribute at > Apache before putting up new votes that would be helpful, ie the vote > would go much smoother if all the issues with the previous vote were > addressed before starting a new one. > > Thanks, > Eli > > On Wed, May 4, 2011 at 5:05 PM, Eric Baldeschwieler > <eri...@yahoo-inc.com> wrote: >> Hi folks, >> >> Let's stay focused. Let's take the other threads onto other threads. This is >> a vote. >> >> To the extent naming is a problem, let's take that to a thread and find an >> acceptable proposal. >> >> To the extent folks want to collaborate on certifying the release for total >> lack of regression or collaborate on the cleanest possible merge, I think >> all interested parties should take these topics to another thread and divide >> up the work. >> >> If you've voted, you don't need to comment further on this thread, no matter >> what company you work for! >> >> Thanks, >> >> --- >> E14 - typing on glass >> >> On May 4, 2011, at 4:46 PM, "Todd Lipcon" <t...@cloudera.com> wrote: >> >>> On Wed, May 4, 2011 at 4:11 PM, Arun C Murthy <a...@yahoo-inc.com> wrote: >>> >>>> On May 4, 2011, at 4:09 PM, Tsz Wo (Nicholas), Sze wrote: >>>> >>>> The list seems highly inaccurate. Checked the first few N/A items. All >>>>> are >>>>> false positives. >>>>> >>>>> >>>> Also, can you please provide a list on features which are not related to >>>> gridmix benchmarks or herriot tests? >>>> >>> >>> Here are a few I quickly pulled up: >>> MAPREDUCE-2316 (docs for improved capacity scheduler) >>> MAPREDUCE-2355 (adds new config for heartbeat dampening in MR) >>> >>> " BZ-4182948. Add statistics logging to Fred for better visibility into >>> startup time costs. (Matt Foley)" >>> - I believe I saw a note from Matt on the JIRA yesterday about this feature, >>> where he decided that the version done in 203 wasn't a good approach, and >>> it's done differently in trunk (not sure if done yet). >>> >>> MAPREDUCE-2364 (important bug fix for localization) >>> - in fact most of localization is different in this branch compared to trunk >>> due to inclusion of MAPREDUCE-2378, the trunk version of which is still on >>> the "yahoo-merge" branch,. >>> >>> "New cunters for FileInput/OutputFormat. New Counter >>> MAP_OUTPUT_MATERIALZIED_BYTES. Related bugs: 4241034, 3418543, >>> 4217546" >>> - not sure which JIRA this is, I think I've seen a JIRA for trunk, but not >>> committed. >>> >>> - MAPREDUCE-1904, committed without JIRA as: >>> " . Reducing new Path(), RawFileStatus() creation overhead in >>> LocalDirAllocator" >>> not in trunk >>> >>> + BZ4101537 . When a queue is built without any access rights we explain >>> the >>> + problem. (dking, rvw ramach) [attachment of 2010-11-24] >>> seems to be on trunk as MR-2411, but not committed, best I can tell, despite >>> the JIRA there being resolved (based on looking at QueueManager in trunk) >>> >>> " . Remove unnecessary reference to user configuration from >>> TaskDistributedCacheManager causing memory leaks" >>> Not in trunk, not sure which JIRA it might be.. probably part of 2178. >>> >>> Major new feature: MAPREDUCE-323 - very large rework of how job history >>> files are managed >>> Major change: MAPREDUCE-1100/MAPREDUCE-1176: unresolved on trunk, though >>> probably will be attacked by different JIRAs >>> Major new ops-visible feature: "metrics2" system >>> Major new ops-visible feature: MAPREDUCE-291 job history can be viewed from >>> a separate server >>> Major new set of user-visible configurations: MAPREDUCE-1943 and friends >>> which implement new limits in MapReduce (eg MAPREDUCE-1872 as well) >>> >>> I have code to work on, so I won't keep going, but this is from looking at >>> the last couple months of 203. >>> >>> -Todd >>> -- >>> Todd Lipcon >>> Software Engineer, Cloudera >> > -- thanks mahadev @mahadevkonar
