On 2 June 2011 21:22, Noel J. Bergman <n...@devtech.com> wrote: > Florian Effenberger wrote: > > > Noel J. Bergman wrote: > > > If there is a community split, that decision will rest solely on those > > > who choose not to join our all-inclusive environment. > > > So, if TDF does not join the Apache OOo project, a community split is > > our (=TDF) fault. However, if the people proposing the Apache incubator > > project do not join TDF, a community split is not their fault. > > > This looks like a rather one-sided view to me > > Charles says that he doesn't want to "enter a debate on licensing." But > licensing is an elephant in the room. Oracle's move with OO.o will fully > open the project to all participants and use-cases, including those who > might previously have had to enter into alternate, paid, licensing > arrangements with the copyright holder. >
Emotionally, ownership (in its broadest sense) is a factor but if we put that aside for a minute, the only real issue *is* licensing. If there was complete agreement on licensing why would there be a need for more than one project? If a developer is totally committed to a copyleft license they might prefer to contribute to a copyleft licensed product development and same for a developer that wants a more permissive license the other way. If you are not bothered either way it won't matter. So the only other practical consideration is whether Apache OOo will get sufficient support. There are 9 names on the commit list which seems surprisingly few to me but maybe everyone is just waiting to see what happens. I'm wondering whether the document foundation could not as its name suggests become more about odf as a format? I helped start the OpenDocument Fellowship with that in mind so I think there is a need. LibreOffice could be a copyleft licensed version of the more liberally licensed Apache code. So on that model all stays much the same but with agreed cooperation to get the best out of it. Main long term problem I see is a potential divergence of the code due to the different licenses but I can't see how that risk can be avoided in the circumstances. --- Noel > > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org > For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org > > -- Ian Ofqual Accredited IT Qualifications The Schools ITQ www.theINGOTs.org +44 (0)1827 305940 You have received this email from the following company: The Learning Machine Limited, Reg Office, 36 Ashby Road, Tamworth, Staffordshire, B79 8AQ. Reg No: 05560797, Registered in England and Wales.