we received a moderated e-mail after we closed the vote. it was sent during the voting phase -> updated result:
thank you for voting! 8 binding +1 votes (ipmc): - Mark Struberg - Jim Jagielski - Matt Benson - Matthias Wessendorf - Christian Grobmeier - Gurkan Erdogdu - David Blevins - Gerhard Petracek 3 non-binding +1 votes: - Joey Echeverria - Bart Kummel - Francis De Brabandere no -1 votes regards, gerhard 2011/12/7 Gerhard Petracek <gpetra...@apache.org> > one vote wasn't listed - corrected result: > > thank you for voting! > > 7 binding +1 votes (ipmc): > - Mark Struberg > - Jim Jagielski > - Matt Benson > - Matthias Wessendorf > - Christian Grobmeier > - Gurkan Erdogdu > - Gerhard Petracek > > 3 non-binding +1 votes: > - Joey Echeverria > - Bart Kummel > - Francis De Brabandere > > no -1 votes > > regards, > gerhard > > > > 2011/12/7 Gerhard Petracek <gpetra...@apache.org> > >> thank you for voting! >> >> 6 binding +1 votes (ipmc): >> - Mark Struberg >> - Matt Benson >> - Matthias Wessendorf >> - Christian Grobmeier >> - Gurkan Erdogdu >> - Gerhard Petracek >> >> 3 non-binding +1 votes: >> - Joey Echeverria >> - Bart Kummel >> - Francis De Brabandere >> >> no -1 votes >> >> regards, >> gerhard >> >> >> >> 2011/12/4 Gerhard Petracek <gpetra...@apache.org> >> >>> Hello, >>> >>> Please vote on the acceptance of DeltaSpike into the Apache Incubator. >>> >>> The proposal is available at [1] and its content is also included below >>> for your convenience. >>> >>> Please vote: >>> >>> [ ] +1 Accept DeltaSpike for incubation >>> [ ] +0 Don't care >>> [ ] -1 Don't accept DeltaSpike for incubation because... >>> >>> The vote is open for 72 hours. >>> >>> Thanks, >>> Gerhard >>> >>> [1] http://wiki.apache.org/incubator/DeltaSpikeProposal >>> >>> ---- >>> >>> Apache DeltaSpike Proposal >>> ====================== >>> >>> >>> >>> Abstract >>> ------------ >>> >>> Apache DeltaSpike is a collection of JSR-299 (CDI) Extensions for >>> building applications on the Java SE and EE platforms. >>> >>> Proposal >>> ------------ >>> >>> Apache DeltaSpike will consist of a number of portable CDI extensions >>> that provide >>> useful features for Java application developers. The goal of Apache >>> DeltaSpike is to create a de-facto standard of extensions that is >>> developed and >>> maintained by the Java community, and to act as an incubator for >>> features that may eventually become part of the various Java SE and >>> EE-related specifications. >>> >>> Background >>> ------------ >>> >>> One of the >>> most exciting inclusions of the Java EE6 specification is JSR-299, >>> Contexts and Dependency Injection (CDI) for Java. CDI builds on other >>> Java EE specifications by defining a contextual component model and >>> typesafe dependency injection framework for managed beans. It also >>> defines a SPI that allows developers to write portable “extensions” that >>> can be used to modify the behaviour of the Java EE platform, by >>> offering additional features not provided by the platform by default. >>> Apache DeltaSpike builds on this portable extensions SPI by providing >>> baseline utilities and CDI Extensions which form the base of almost all >>> CDI applications. >>> >>> Rationale >>> ------------ >>> >>> There presently exists a number of open source projects that provide >>> extensions for CDI, such as Apache MyFaces CODI, JBoss Seam3 and >>> CDISource. Apache DeltaSpike seeks to unify these efforts by creating an >>> “industry standard” set of extensions, combining the best core features of >>> these projects. The >>> project also aims to provide a rich, JBoss Arquillian based (license: >>> ALv2), test environment to ensure that DeltaSpike portably runs in all >>> important CDI environments. >>> >>> Initial Goals >>> ------------ >>> >>> The initial goals of the Apache DeltaSpike project are to: >>> * Setup the governance structure of the project >>> * Receive code donations from contributing members >>> * Ensure all donated code is appropriately licensed under the Apache >>> License >>> * Merge and rename code to reflect new project name >>> * Merge code where feature overlap exists >>> * Merge or produce documentation for all modules >>> * Provide simple examples demonstrating feature usage >>> * Produce release/s based on a schedule created by the PMC >>> * Attract contributions from the greater Java EE community and other >>> Java EE development groups >>> >>> Current Status >>> ------------ >>> >>> The initial codebase for Apache DeltaSpike will be populated with >>> mature code donations from project members, including JBoss Seam3, Apache >>> MyFaces CODI and CDISource. >>> >>> Meritocracy >>> ------------ >>> >>> All >>> contributors have a well established history in the open source >>> community and are well aware of the meritocracy principles of the Apache >>> Software Foundation. >>> Currently the Seam3 project is fortunate to receive the majority of its >>> code >>> contributions from its large community of users. Many of the modules >>> that are contained in the Seam project are led by volunteers from the >>> community, who have both direct commit access, and discretion over the >>> direction of their modules. >>> Apache MyFaces CODI is a subproject of Apache MyFaces and thus all >>> contributors are already familiar with the meritocracy principles. >>> The CDISource project has adopted the principles of meritocracy by the >>> founding developers having control of different modules depending on >>> their contribution to those modules. >>> >>> Community >>> ------------ >>> >>> The JBoss Seam, Apache MyFaces CODI and CDISource projects already have >>> well established communities, consisting of many active users and >>> contributors. One of the primary >>> goals of the Apache DeltaSpike project is to unify this community, and >>> by creating a project that is a “single source of truth” for CDI >>> Extensions. By doing this, we hope >>> to make the whole greater than the sum of its parts, i.e. to >>> attract a much stronger community than that which currently exists >>> across the separate projects. To this end, it is a goal of this >>> project to attract contributors from the Java EE community in addition >>> to those from the three projects already mentioned. >>> >>> Core Developers >>> ------------ >>> * Shane Bryzak (Red Hat) >>> * Jason Porter (Red Hat) >>> * Stuart Douglas (Red Hat) >>> * Jozef Hartinger (Red Hat) >>> * Brian Leathem (Red Hat) >>> * Ken Finnigan (Red Hat) >>> * Marius Bogoevici (Red Hat) >>> * Pete Muir (Red Hat) >>> * George Gastaldi (Independent contributor) >>> * John Ament (Independent contributor) >>> * Cody Lerum (Independent contributor) >>> * Antoine Sabot-Durand (Independent contributor) >>> * Pete Royle (Independent contributor) >>> * Mark Struberg (individual, ASF member) >>> * Gerhard Petracek (individual, ASF member) >>> * David Blevins (individual, ASF member) >>> * Matthias Wessendorf (individual, ASF member) >>> * Jakob Korherr (individual, ASF committer) >>> * Andy Gibson (Independent contributor) >>> * Rick Hightower (Independent contributor) >>> * Rob Williams (Independent contributor) >>> >>> Alignment >>> ------------ >>> >>> The Apache DeltaSpike project is intended to be portable, and be fully >>> compatible with any >>> compliant Java EE6 container. To promote the adoption of this project, >>> we believe that it is important that it remains free from corporate >>> association and is perceived by the community to be vendor neutral. To >>> this end, the Apache Software Foundation with its values of >>> transparency and community makes it an excellent fit for this project, >>> not to mention that one of the contributing members (Apache MyFaces >>> CODI) is already an Apache project. >>> >>> Known Risks >>> ------------ >>> >>> While many of the contributors to the Apache DeltaSpike project are >>> volunteers, the initial effort of setting up the project >>> and driving ongoing releases may fall to corporate-sponsored members. >>> It is recognized that there may be a slight risk based on the >>> dependence of salaried contributors, however it can safely be said that >>> most if not all of these contributors began as community volunteers >>> that recognized the merit of the project and began contributing as a >>> result of their own passion. >>> Documentation >>> ------------ >>> >>> Documentation for the existing projects can be found as follows: >>> * JBoss Seam - >>> http://docs.jboss.org/seam/3/latest/reference/en-US/html/ >>> * Apache MyFaces CODI - >>> https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/EXTCDI/Documentation >>> * CDISource - http://cdisource.org/site/ >>> Documentation for the Apache DeltaSpike project would be created by >>> combining and editing material from the >>> above sources, in addition to the writing of new material where >>> required. >>> >>> Initial Source >>> ------------ >>> >>> Source code contributions for the Apache DeltaSpike project would be >>> made from its member projects, and the initial goal would be to provide a >>> common core extension which contains a number of features considered >>> essential for building other extensions. Tests for this common core will be >>> developed using the Arquillian integration testing framework, allowing >>> the extension to be automatically tested extensively across various CDI >>> implementations and EE servers in the interest of providing a stable >>> foundation for building other extensions. >>> The ongoing goal of the project will be to gradually incorporate >>> additional features as determined by the PPMC, extending on the >>> foundation features provided by the common core. >>> >>> Source and IP Submission Plan >>> ------------ >>> >>> The following resources will be moved to Apache infrastructure under the >>> Apache DeltaSpike project name: >>> * Core JBoss Seam 3 codebase. Seam 3 is already licensed under the >>> Apache License V2. >>> * Seam Core Reference Documentation >>> * Apache MyFaces CODI codebase >>> * Apache MyFaces CODI documentation >>> * CDISource codebase under the Apache License V2 >>> The existing Seam, MyFaces CODI and CDISource trademarks will be >>> retained by their respective owners. >>> >>> External Dependencies >>> ------------ >>> >>> The following external dependencies have been identified: >>> * Apache Maven - Java based build tool - Apache License 2.0, >>> (non-runtime) >>> * Arquillian - Java EE integration testing framework - Apache >>> License 2.0, (non-runtime) >>> * Shrinkwrap - Java deployment packaging - Apache License 2.0 >>> (non-runtime) >>> * various Java EE API packages - all Apache License 2.0 (non-runtime) >>> >>> >>> >>> Required Resources >>> ---------------------- >>> >>> >>> Mailing Lists >>> ------------ >>> >>> * deltaspike-us...@incubator.apache.org >>> * deltaspike-...@incubator.apache.org >>> * deltaspike-comm...@incubator.apache.org >>> * deltaspike-priv...@incubator.apache.org >>> >>> Version Control >>> ------------ >>> >>> It is proposed that the source code for the Apache DeltaSpike project >>> be hosted in the Apache Git repository, under the following directory: >>> * incubator/deltaspike/ >>> >>> Issue Tracking >>> ------------ >>> >>> The following JIRA project would be required to track issues for the >>> Apache DeltaSpike project: >>> * DELTASPIKE >>> >>> Initial Committers >>> ------------ >>> >>> * Shane Bryzak (sbryzak at gmail.com) >>> * Jason Porter (lightguard.jp at gmail.com) >>> * Stuart Douglas (stuart.w.douglas at gmail.com) >>> * Jozef Hartinger (jozefhartinger at gmail.com) >>> * Brian Leathem (bleathem at gmail.com) >>> * Ken Finnigan (ken at kenfinnigan.me) >>> * Marius Bogoevici (mariusb at redhat.com) >>> * George Gastaldi (gegastaldi at gmail.com) >>> * John Ament (john.d.ament at gmail.com) >>> * Cody Lerum (cody.lerum at clearfly.net) >>> * Antoine Sabot-Durand (antoine at sabot-durand.net) >>> * Pete Royle (pete at screamingcoder.com) >>> * Pete Muir (pmuir at redhat.com) >>> * Mark Struberg (struberg at apache dot org) >>> * Gerhard Petracek (gpetracek at apache dot org) >>> * David Blevins (dblevins at apache dot org) >>> * Matthias Wessendorf (matzew at apache dot org) >>> * Jakob Korherr (jakobk at apache dot org) >>> * Andy Gibson (contact at andygibson.net) >>> * Rick Hightower (richardhightower at gmail.com) >>> >>> Affiliations >>> ------------ >>> >>> The following contributors are full time employees of Red Hat: >>> * Shane Bryzak >>> * Jason Porter >>> * Stuart Douglas >>> * Jozef Hartinger >>> * Brian Leathem >>> * Ken Finnigan >>> * Marius Bogoevici >>> * Pete Muir >>> >>> Sponsors >>> ------------ >>> >>> Champion >>> ------------ >>> >>> * Mark Struberg >>> >>> Nominated Mentors >>> ------------ >>> >>> * Mark Struberg >>> * Gerhard Petracek >>> * David Blevins >>> * Matthias Wessendorf >>> * Matt Benson >>> >>> Sponsoring Entity >>> ------------ >>> >>> * Apache MyFaces PMC >>> >>> Project Name >>> ------------ >>> While DeltaSpike is intended to be used as the project’s code name >>> during the >>> incubation process, it is intended that we will solicit suggestions >>> from the greater community for a more suitable name before it becomes a >>> top level project at Apache. >>> >> >> >
