Hi Justin, I'll comment here as well On 2020/10/08 04:34:34, Justin Mclean <jus...@classsoftware.com> wrote: > Hi, > > I didi my usual check and most things look good, but I can see a couple of > minor things. Hopefully the mentors can comment on the following: > - Logo is missing form logos.apache.org
There is no such subdomain... can you double check the URL? Thank you > - A few of the proposed PMC are not subscribed to the private list (Alex, > Laura, Steve) I will encourage them to join. Thanks for pointing that out. > - It’s been a long time since the project added any committers (Looks like > the last was Arthi on 2017-01-24?) Correct. I understand that this may indicate that the project is not attracting contributors but I have never seen this as a blocker for graduation. There are plenty of TLP's that have a small committer base and who have not added committters in a while. Apache Any23 is one example that I know. > - There doesn’t seem to be a lot of traffic on the mailing lists (dev and > especially user) Correct. Again, this is a small project with a small user base. I don't think that this blocks graduation though. > - There seems to be several products (UserALE, Distill, Tap and Stout) but I > only see release votes for UserALE. How are the other products released? They are not released and will not be. They are deprecated as indicated on the Website. > - There also seem to be a python version of UserALE but I don’t see any > release votes for it either. Correct. It was never released. > - The last four board reports have listed the same goals to reach graduation. > Has any progress been made on these? Based on the October2020 report (https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/INCUBATOR/October2020#flagon) we following are defined Work with IPMC to approve draft graduation resolution (blocking) Update release practices to be consistent with NPM, Python registry (non-blocking) Push new UserALE.js release (non-blocking) This looks good to me and reflects reality. Do you have any further comments? Thanks Justin lewismc --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org
