On Mon, Aug 4, 2008 at 4:11 PM, Ciaran McCreesh <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On Mon, 4 Aug 2008 16:06:11 -0700 > "Alec Warner" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> On Mon, Aug 4, 2008 at 11:29 AM, Stephen Bennett >> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> > I would like to put forward the following suggestion for the >> > Council's consideration: >> > >> > "While the current state of PMS is not perfect, it is a reasonably >> > close approximation to existing and historical behaviour of EAPI 0. >> > Given this, and that getting a perfect definition is not feasible >> > on a timescale shorter than several years, it should be treated as >> > a draft standard, and any deviations from it found in the gentoo >> > tree or package managers should have a bug filed against either the >> > deviator or PMS to resolve the differences. >> >> Is this not already the status quo? Surely a number of bugs in the >> tree have already been fixed in this manner. > > Currently some developers are quite happy to fix issues, whilst others > prefer to yell "Portage is the only supported package manager and if it > works for me with Portage you can go to hell"...
So assuming the council says we should fix all these issues (and in most cases I would support that assertion) who would fix them? The maintainer is obviously hostile and I doubt the council is going to *force* them to accept said patches. Is QA going to fix these bugs? > > Also, some developers seem quite happy making changes to Portage that > break existing packages that rely upon behaviour as defined by PMS, > under the assertion that "PMS is too much like a rulebook"... Also some developers seem quite happy making changes to PMS that break existing packages that rely upon behavior as defined by Portage; under the assertion that "Portage is a broken/buggy piece of software" That being said you are free to chat to Zac about the changes; I doubt you can compel him to comply with PMS 100% unless this is driven by developers themselves. He (not unlike me) is kind of a pragmatic fellow. -Alec > > -- > Ciaran McCreesh >
