github  

Messages by Date

• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Allow flag to alias all prjected substrait expressions with a UUID [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] feat: Preserve File Partitioning From File Scans [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] minor: Move shuffle logic to CometShuffleExchangeExec [datafusion-comet] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] chore: Exec rule refactor contd [WIP] [datafusion-comet] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Always remove unecessary software from github runners for all jobs (fix intermittent out of space on runners) [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Always remove unecessary software from github runners for all jobs [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] Allow flag to alias all prjected substrait expressions with a UUID [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Tracking: Explicitly add `CoalesceBatches` physical rule [datafusion-ballista] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Tracking: Explicitly add `CoalesceBatches` physical rule [datafusion-ballista] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] feat: Add support for `explode` and `explode_outer` for array inputs [datafusion-comet] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Add support for Spark SQL `explode` expression [datafusion-comet] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] feat: Add support for `explode` and `explode_outer` for array inputs [datafusion-comet] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Implement physical and logical codecs in FFI [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Implement physical and logical codecs in FFI [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Move the `DefaultMetadataCache` into its own module [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Always remove unecessary software from github runners for all jobs [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Misleading error message when `CREATE EXTERNAL TABLE` with invalid path [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Always remove unecessary software from github runners for all jobs [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] Always remove unecessary software from all github runners [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Preserve FIle Partitioning [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Preserve FIle Partitioning [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Move the `DefaultMetadataCache` into its own module [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Add builder API for `CreateExternalTable` to reduce redundancy and make the code easier to understand [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] feat: Add builder API for CreateExternalTable to reduce verbosity [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] feat: Add builder API for CreateExternalTable to reduce verbosity [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] feat: Add builder API for CreateExternalTable to reduce verbosity [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [I] extended test / hash collisions job is intermittently failing due to out of disk space [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Adds memory-bound DefaultListFilesCache [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Run the examples in the new format [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] refactor: move human readable display utilities to `datafusion-common` crate [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Add relation planner extension support to customize SQL planning [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Push down projection expressions into ParquetOpener [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Push down projection expressions into ParquetOpener [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Add sorted data benchmark. [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Push down projection expressions into ParquetOpener [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [I] Update to_date udf function to support a consistent set of argument types [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Temporarily ignore test_cache_with_ttl_and_lru test [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Temporarily ignore test_cache_with_ttl_and_lru test [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [I] Update to_unixtime udf function to support a consistent set of argument types [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] [Proto]: Serialization support for `AsyncFuncExec` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] use ProjectionExprs:project_statistics in FileScanConfig [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Projection fails on TPCDS Q13 [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] use ProjectionExprs:project_statistics in FileScanConfig [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] `Statistics::total_byte_size` does not account for projection in `FileScanConfig::with_projection` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Update to_timestamp udf functions to have a consistent set of supported argument types [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [I] Update to_timestamp udf functions to have a consistent set of supported argument types [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Implement physical and logical codecs in FFI [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [I] Add ability to remove optimizer rules from `SessionContext` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] use ProjectionExprs:project_statistics in FileScanConfig [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: optimize CASE WHEN lookup table (2.5-22.5 times faster) [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] feat(spark): Implement Spark functions `url_encode`, `url_decode` and `try_url_decode` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] chore: Add TPCDS benchmarks [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Adds memory-bound DefaultListFilesCache [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] Temporarily ignore test_cache_with_ttl_and_lru test [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Update Committer / PMC list [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Intermittent CI failures in `cache::list_files_cache::tests::test_cache_with_ttl_and_lru` ( seems flaky) [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [I] Intermittent CI failures in `cache::list_files_cache::tests::test_cache_with_ttl_and_lru` ( seems flaky) [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Push down projection expressions into ParquetOpener [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] Track column sizes in Statistics; propagate through projections [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] use ProjectionExprs:project_statistics in FileScanConfig [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: optimize CASE WHEN lookup table (2.5-22.5 times faster) [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] [datafusion-cli] Implement average LIST duration for object store profiling [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] [datafusion-cli] Implement average LIST duration for object store profiling [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Add relation planner extension support to customize SQL planning [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [I] Support ser/de of `AsyncFuncExec` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Partitioned object store lists all files on every query when using hive-partitioned parquet files [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Add relation planner extension support to customize SQL planning [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Add relation planner extension support to customize SQL planning [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Add relation planner extension support to customize SQL planning [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] `"UTMMedium"` field in the hits dataset causes a panic when performing SIMILAR TO. [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Add relation planner extension support to customize SQL planning [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] fix: NativeScan count assert firing for no reason [datafusion-comet] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Update Committer / PMC list [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] NativeScan count assertion fires needleslly [datafusion-comet] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] feat: Add expression registry to native planner [datafusion-comet] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Parquet stats pruning: `IS NULL/IS NOT NULL` Simplification for Literal Arguments [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] Push down projection expressions into ParquetOpener [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] Fix flaky spill_pool channel test and clarify channel usage example [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Respect execution timezone in to_timestamp and related functions [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] feat: support Set Comparison Subquery [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Support deep schema pruning and projection [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: skip hash aggregation multi group by for already not found [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: skip hash aggregation multi group by for already not found [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Run the examples in the new format [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Run the examples in the new format [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] add config options for list_files_cache_limit and list_files_cache_ttl [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: skip hash aggregation multi group by for already not found [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: skip hash aggregation multi group by for already not found [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: skip hash aggregation multi group by for already not found [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] LEFT JOIN with FixedSizeBinary join keys returns incorrect values instead of NULL [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] LEFT JOIN with FixedSizeBinary join keys returns incorrect values instead of NULL [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: skip hash aggregation multi group by for already not found [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: skip hash aggregation multi group by for already not found [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: skip hash aggregation multi group by for already not found [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] perf: skip hash aggregation multi group by for already not found [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] docs: include NestedLoopJoinExec metrics in EXPLAIN ANALYZE guide (issue #19045) [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] bench: set test_util as required feature for aggregate_vectorized [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] refactor: Refactor spark width bucket signature away from user defined [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Regression: `DataFrameWriteOptions::with_single_file_output` produces a directory [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] `CREATE TYPE` without `AS` fails parsing. [datafusion-sqlparser-rs] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Align more uniformely the table constraints and column options [datafusion-sqlparser-rs] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Adds memory-bound DefaultListFilesCache [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Respect execution timezone in to_timestamp and related functions [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Respect execution timezone in to_timestamp and related functions [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Respect execution timezone in to_timestamp and related functions [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] Added support for `ALTER OPERATOR FAMILY` syntax [datafusion-sqlparser-rs] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Add sorted data benchmark. [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Update Committer / PMC list [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Parquet stats pruning: `IS NULL/IS NOT NULL` Simplification for Literal Arguments [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Preserve FIle Partitioning [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Run the examples in the new format [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Add relation planner extension support to customize SQL planning [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Coalesce batches inside hash join, reuse indices buffer [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Add sorted data benchmark. [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Run the examples in the new format [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Add sorted data benchmark. [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Update Committer / PMC list [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Run the examples in the new format [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 [PR] Update Committer / PMC lis [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [D] DISCUSSION: DataFusion Meetup in Stockholm, Sweden [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Add sorted data benchmark. [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] feat: integrate batch coalescer with repartition exec [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Add sorted data benchmark. [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Add sorted data benchmark. [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] Coalesce batches inside hash join, reuse indices buffer [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Integrate cast_column into PhysicalExprAdapter [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] chore: Add TPCDS benchmarks [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] fix: escape underscores when simplifying `starts_with` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [I] Integrate cast_column into PhysicalExprAdapter [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] fix: fix panic when lo is greater than hi [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] run cargo fmt to fix after #18998 [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/05 Re: [PR] run cargo fmt to fix after #18998 [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [I] [Docs] Update SQL examples in documentation for timestamp/datetime functions [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 [I] [Docs] Update SQL examples in documentation for timestamp/datetime functions [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Cut `Parquet` over to PhysicalExprAdapter, remove `SchemaAdapter` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 [PR] perf: change vectorized equal to in multi column aggregation to use `BooleanBufferBuilder` instead of `&[bool]` [WIP] [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Cut `Parquet` over to PhysicalExprAdapter, remove `SchemaAdapter` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 [PR] run cargo fmt to fix after #18998 [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] fix: NativeScan count assert firing for no reason [datafusion-comet] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Cut `Parquet` over to PhysicalExprAdapter, remove `SchemaAdapter` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 [PR] bench: set test_util as required feature for aggregate_vectorized [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] perf: optimize CASE WHEN lookup table (2.5-22.5 times faster) [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] perf: optimize CASE WHEN lookup table (2.5-22.5 times faster) [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] fix: escape underscores when simplifying `starts_with` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Run the examples in the new format [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Run the examples in the new format [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] perf: optimize CASE WHEN lookup table (2.5-22.5 times faster) [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Run the examples in the new format [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Run the examples in the new format [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Cut `Parquet` over to PhysicalExprAdapter, remove `SchemaAdapter` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Cut `Parquet` over to PhysicalExprAdapter, remove `SchemaAdapter` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Fix Schema Duplication Errors in Self‑Referential INTERSECT/EXCEPT by Requalifying Input Sides [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [I] [substrait] [sqllogictest] Schema contains duplicate qualified field name [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Fix Schema Duplication Errors in Self‑Referential INTERSECT/EXCEPT by Requalifying Input Sides [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] feat(spark): implement spark hash function murmur/xxhash64 [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] feat: change Expr OuterReferenceColumn and Alias to Box type for reducing expr struct size [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] fix: repartition for grouping set [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Adds script to detect breaking API changes/ semver [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Unnest Correlated Subquery [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [D] DISCUSSION: DataFusion Meetup in Stockholm, Sweden [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [D] DISCUSSION: DataFusion Meetup in Stockholm, Sweden [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [D] DISCUSSION: DataFusion Meetup in Stockholm, Sweden [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] fix: fix panic when lo is greater than hi [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Added alter external table support for snowflake [datafusion-sqlparser-rs] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 [PR] Remove unused CastColumnExpr [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Consolidate `CastColumnExpr` with `CastColumn` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 [PR] fix: fix panic when lo is greater than high [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Support parsing parenthesized wildcard `(*)` [datafusion-sqlparser-rs] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [I] Panic in approx_percentile_cont [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] refactor: move human readable display utilities to `datafusion-common` crate [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] refactor: move human readable display utilities to `datafusion-common` crate [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 [I] Track individual column sizes in `Statistics` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Cut `Parquet` over to PhysicalExprAdapter, remove `SchemaAdapter` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] fix: NativeScan count assert firing for no reason [datafusion-comet] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] feat: Add expression registry to native planner [WIP] [datafusion-comet] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Fix function doc CI check [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [I] Preserve FIle Partitioning [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 [PR] feat: Add expression registry to native planner [WIP] [datafusion-comet] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [I] Enable Parallel Aggregation for Non-Overlapping Partitioned Data [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] fix: NativeScan count assert firing for no reason [datafusion-comet] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Cut `Parquet` over to PhysicalExprAdapter, remove `SchemaAdapter` [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Cut Parquet over to PhysicalExprAdapter from SchemaAdapter [datafusion] via GitHub
• 2025/12/04 Re: [PR] Consolidate `CastColumnExpr` with `CastColumn` [datafusion] via GitHub

• Earlier messages
• Later messages