Merijn de Weerd wrote: > On 2006-05-14, Eric <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> Well, suppose, hypothetically, that you added a lot of code to the >> kernel/base distribution, stripped out some of the base distribution >> stuff (like X or whaever) too in order to create a really robust and >> unique testing environment for testing new computer systems. You'd want >> to keep that inhouse to prevent your competition from gaining the same >> advantage that you just worked months or years to create. > > Suppose you add a lot of code to implement a really robust and > unique embedded software stack that makes a great product. You'd > want to keep that proprietary to prevent your competition from > gaining the same advantage that you just worked months or years to > create. Yet, you have to share if you build upon GPL software. > The same should apply to the in-house environment you describe. > > About the only real justification I can think of is when > the code simply isn't ready for release. You don't want to > be forced to publish every interim release or internal beta. > > Merijn > so its basically "if i modify any gpl'd code I must give away my changes whether or not i keep it 'in-house' "? Wow, if i have that right, then thats about the very best way i know of to prevent any company from using a kernel as a base for their own proprietary needs. Its like saying: Here's a hammer and some nails, do what you want with it, but if you build a house you have to build one for your neighbor too. In your example, you left out that your competitor who makes the same embedded product, just took your 2 years of development efforts and got them for free while you spent all the up front costs in programmers, computers, etc to develop it no thanks to him and now you have to just give it to him? No Way! how is that a good idea? If thats really the way it is, then a company would be far smarter to pay a license fee up front and own the base code. Eric
_______________________________________________ gnu-misc-discuss mailing list [email protected] http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/gnu-misc-discuss
