On 2012-09-14, at 3:00 AM, SUGITA Shigeki wrote: > Congratulations on BOAI's new reccomendations! > > The Digital Repository Federation (DRF) in Japan > is now translating it into Japanese and will soon privide it. > > I am a member of the translation staff. > >> 1.1. Every institution of higher education should have >> a policy assuring that peer-reviewed versions of all >> future scholarly articles by faculty members are deposited >> in the institution’s designated repository. (See >> recommendation 3.1 on institutional repositories.) > >> University policies should respect faculty freedom to >> submit new work to the journals of their choice. > >> 1.3. Every research funding agency, public or private, >> should have a policy assuring that peer-reviewed versions >> of all future scholarly articles reporting funded research >> are deposited in a suitable repository and made OA as >> soon as practicable. > >> When publishers will not allow OA on the funder’s terms, >> funder policies should require grantees to seek another publisher. > > Feeling a mismatch between these clauses, I am at a loss > for word selection. I am not so good at English. My misunderstanding?
You are right to point out this difference in the recommendations for (1) institutions and for (2) funders. Please note that I am replying as one individual co-drafter and co-signatory. I am not speaking for all of us, nor for the Soros Foundation. The rationale was that there are some factors over which institutions have more prerogatives than funders, and there are some factors over which funders have more prerogatives than institutions. (1) Institutions, because they employ researchers to do the highest quality research can require researchers to publish their findings in the journals with the highest quality standards. This can be reflected in how institutions evaluate the research performance of their researchers, assigning higher weight to work that has met the standards of journals that have higher quality standards. (Often in practice the quality of a journal is inferred in part from its average citation count ["impact factor"], which is a metric that has been much criticized. This is a complicated and controversial issue. The computation and use of metrics is currently evolving, partly under the influence of open access itself.) (2) Funders, because they pay for and dictate the conditions for the grants they award, have slightly different criteria and prerogatives. They too want research to be of high quality, but they are also in a position to make public access to publicly funded research a condition of the funding. And the larger funding agencies (such as NIH) fund so much research that they have a sizeable potential influence on journal policy (e.g., embargo lengths) -- an influence that most individual institutions do not have. Hence funders can, in principle, stipulate that the research must be made open access, as a contractual obligation preceding its having been submitted to any journal. As a consequence, journals would either have to honor this prior contractual obligation or not accept the work for publication. Note that some institutions with a particularly heavy weight have taken a route somewhat similar to this, notably Harvard and MIT. Their (Green) open access mandates stipulate that their authors are contractually bound to make their published articles open access unless the authors explicitly seek a waiver from the policy. The Harvard/MIT-style copyright retention mandate, however, is just one of several differenct kinds of mandate models or mandate condtions that an institution might adopt. And, as noted, in general, individual institutions do not have the weight of research funders in influencing journal policy. So -- and here, although what I've said so far is largely generic, I am speaking as an individual interpreter of the BOAI10 recommendations -- the feeling was that BOAI should not single out which Green OA mandate conditions an institution should adopt, beyond recommending that deposit should be immediate, embargoes should be as short as possible, and re-use rights should be as broad as possible, whereas funders could also adopt constraints on journal choice other than just journal importance and quality. The unknowns here are researchers themselves, whose needs vary from discipline to discipline. Some authors, in some fields, may be happy to exercise their choice of journal in such a way as to comply with institutional open access policy -- others may prefer a waiver, in order to publish in the journal they find most appropriate. It is, quite frankly, a conjecture whether a constraint on authors' journal choice, in the interests of open access, will prove successful for funder mandates. It should accordingly be born in mind that the BOAI recommendations are just recommendations; that they vary in their importance, generality and urgency, as well as in the degree to which they are supported by prior evidence and experience. Recommended constraints by funders on authors' journal choice fall in this more provisional category. Not all the co-drafters and co-signatories were equally sanguine about them. Stevan Harnad _______________________________________________ GOAL mailing list [email protected] http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal
