Peter,

Two months ago, that is, on January 27, we started work at Elsevier to make 
available as much as possible of the scholarly literature on coronavirus 
research easily discoverable and freely accessible.

At 1science, we created the Coronavirus Research Hub:

https://coronavirus.1science.com/search

This hub contains more than 36,000 bibliographic records from scholarly 
journals on coronavirus research which we are harvesting from all around the 
world. Like all papers in 1findr, they cover every fields of knowledge and all 
language. We’re working continuously to expand the collection yet we are 
concerned to keep it a tight collection to make the literature as relevant as 
possible.

Of these, a full 20,000 articles are freely downloadable. Everyone concerned at 
Elsevier from the top to the bottom, and the bottom to the top has work to make 
all Elsevier coronavirus-related literature freely available. Elsevier is not 
alone and many other publishers have unlocked their articles.

If we can help further, please let us know, we have been on it for two months 
and we continue to evaluate options to help the research community.

Yours sincerely

Éric

Eric Archambault
Vice-Président | ELSEVIER | Vice-President
Directeur général | 1science | General Manager
3863 St-Laurent, suite 206  | Montréal, QC, Canada  | H2W 1Y1
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
+1.438.356.4619
[cid:[email protected]]<https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4422-1054>  
[cid:[email protected]] 
<https://www.linkedin.com/in/ericarchambault>

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Peter 
Murray-Rust
Sent: March 30, 2020 12:45 PM
To: Global Open Access List (Successor of AmSci) <[email protected]>
Subject: [GOAL] COVID-19 and access to knowledge

We've launched a site https://github.com/petermr/openVirus to search the whole 
open literature for content  which could help tackle the pandemic. We're 
looking for volunteers (tech, biblio/library, documenters to help).

Background
=========
It's now clear that knowledge is one of the key tools in tackling this COVID-19 
epidemic, and also that citizens across the world are desperate for knowledge. 
To address this some organizations are releasing restrictions on all IP as long 
as the epidemic lasts + 1 year.
https://opencovidpledge.org/

>>>>Immediate action is required to halt the COVID-19 Pandemic and treat those 
>>>>it has affected. It is a practical and moral imperative that every tool we 
>>>>have at our disposal be applied to develop and deploy technologies on a 
>>>>massive scale without impediment.

We therefore pledge to make all intellectual property under our control 
available to any group or individual for use in ending the COVID-19 pandemic 
and minimizing the impact of the disease, free of charge and without 
encumbrances.

We will implement this pledge expeditiously in accordance with the rules and 
regulations under which we operate.
<<<<

The COVID-19 outbreak has drawn a minimal response from Scholarly publishing, 
both commercial and academic (e.g. repositories). One publisher, The Royal 
Society, has made ALL its publications freely accessible without restriction. 
This is the minimum that makes any difference.
The only other response I know of is CORD-19 dataset 
(https://cset.georgetown.edu/covid-19-open-research-dataset-cord-19/)
>>>>


CORD-19 contains 29,000 full-text articles with a wealth of information about 
the novel coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2), the associated illness COVID-19, and 
related viruses. The collection will be updated as new research is published in 
peer-reviewed publications and archival services like 
bioRxiv<https://www.biorxiv.org/>, medRxiv<https://www.medrxiv.org/>, and 
others.

At the request of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, CSET 
leads this effort in partnership with the Allen Institute for AI, Chan 
Zuckerberg Initiative, Microsoft Research and the National Library of Medicine 
of the National Institutes of Health.
<<<<
I have worked with this dataset and had helpful discussions with Allen AI. But 
I believe this response is minimal and can be only used by a very small 
proportion of the world. (I have no criticism of Allen AI, but  I have a major 
criticism of the scholarly publishing industry).

This dataset (29 K) is a minute fraction of scholarly publication relevant to 
epidemics, between 0.1-1% . Half of it is public anyway in Europe/PMC and *rxiv 
so the amount contributed by publishers is even less. It assumes that (a) the 
publishers know what people want (they don't) and (b) that the only people who 
need to get help are datamining AI academics. The data set is not readable by 
humans (the papers have been cast into JSON and the metadata removed into a 
separate CSV file).

The terms "COVID", "SARS", "coronavirus" only reach a small amount of the 
literature. I'm on a Cambridge Slack where my colleagues are discussing many 
different aspects of tackling the epidemic. Here are some:
* aerosols
* communications
* early detection
* epidemic modelling
* law
* masks
* molecular modelling
* strategy
* surfaces
* ventilators

None of these will be in CORD-19.

It's clear that some strategies depend heavily on human behaviour and political 
systems. We need papers on history, law, psychology, economics, literature, 
maths, statistics, education, politics ...
... in fact everything

Every subject researched in University is relevant to this fight.
And the majority of citizens will be able to understand and use a large amount 
of the scholarly literature. You don't need to know quantum mechanics to read 
papers on how previous epidemics have been controlled.

Humans now must have a basic right to read any publicly funded research without 
restriction. Charging them 35-50 USD to read a single paper for one day is an 
insult. CEO's trumpeting what a great contribution CORD-19 is is unbearably 
arrogant. People are losing their livelihoods and lives, yet they are being 
charged exorbitant amounts to read about how to stay alive.

"food rationing" is a possible strategy in compliance.  I've searched Elsevier 
and Taylor and Francis for this and of the top 20/25 hits there is ZERO access 
to citizens, even for papers 50 years old. It's time we started thinking about 
READERS, not authors.

It's also critical that we use machines to read the ALL literature as it is 
published - perhaps 10K / day. And also theses. It's not a huge task, it's just 
horribly messy because we don't have tradition of wanting the output to be read 
or used. (If we had, the Ebola outbreak prediction would have been made public 
many years ago).

The only modern way to use the fruits of public scholarship are:
* create all material openly
* with a semantic version
* review as necessary in public
* remove any access barriers to authoring or reading or re-using
* use machines to process all material and index it with a single point of 
access. (Individual publishers with own brands are a massive friction in the 
system. Individual university repositories are massive friction. )
* annotate, split, combine, compute. The human/machine readership should be the 
judge of what's useful and needed.
* pay for service, not rent/ownership. The preprint servers have shown that the 
costs are very low. Latin America has shown that the costs are very low.

This means that publishers must adapt or die. Other industries are doing that - 
planes, manufacturing , food, ... People are dying. There is no longer a right 
to make money by restricting access to knowledge (Paywalls, lawyers, Glass 
screens, etc.). Publishers - if they are needed at all - must put the 
dissemination of public knowledge at the top of their mission.

And if you've read this polemic this far, and have something to contribute,
https://github.com/petermr/openVirus







--
"I always retain copyright in my papers, and nothing in any contract I sign 
with any publisher will override that fact. You should do the same".

Peter Murray-Rust
Reader Emeritus in Molecular Informatics
Unilever Centre, Dept. Of Chemistry
University of Cambridge
CB2 1EW, UK
+44-1223-763069
_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal

Reply via email to