Iljitsch van Beijnum wrote, around 7/11/07 8:38 PM:
On 7 nov 2007, at 11:29, Richard Pruss wrote:
I suggest you address that question in a liaison from the IETF to the
chairs of the DSLForum architecture group if you expect a serious
answer on what the overall DSL architecture is for IPv6.
How is doing that helpful in our evaluation of the request made by the
DSL Forum along with the notion that DHCP is the right solution for this?
The lack of ANY discussion of IPv6 coupled with the fact that DHCP is
fundamentally incompatible with IPv6 as good as impunes this entire
excercise.
I do not see DHCP as being "fundamentally incompatible" with IPv6.
I'm not seeing any progress here. I think it's time to wrap all of this
up and tell the DSL Forum that what they want can't be blessed by the
IETF so either they're going to do what they're going to do without that
blessing or they start PARTICIPATING in the IETF process in some way
rather than restate the same thing until the IETF produces the desired
result.
Please bear in mine that I am not the DSLForum and I would not project
you irritation with me onto the DSLForum.
- Ric
Chairs: I suggest that it's time for a consensus call of some kind.
_______________________________________________
Int-area mailing list
[email protected]
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/int-area
