> On 19 Jan 2015, at 07:52, Rasmus Lerdorf <ras...@lerdorf.com> wrote: > > On 01/18/2015 02:08 PM, Rasmus Lerdorf wrote: >> We have to be really really careful with this "oh, that code is wrong, >> so we can break it argument". This will break hundreds if not thousands >> of sites in a hard-to-debug way. It took me less than a minute of >> looking on Github to find a case that will break: >> >> https://github.com/chenboking/service.downloadmanager.amule/blob/cda510415f9a58660e096a7de42b3ea6f39ee851/webserver/php-default/amuleweb-main-search.php#L121 >> >> It is extremely common to just do a less-than or a greater-than check in >> a user comparison function. Of course it isn't textbook-correct, but >> since it has always worked, people do it. > > And just to further illustrate this, I just downloaded the current > Wordpress release and sure enough, Wordpress would also be broken by > this change. > > In http://core.svn.wordpress.org/trunk/wp-includes/class-simplepie.php > look at the sort_items() method: > > /** > * Sorting callback for items > * > * @access private > * @param SimplePie $a > * @param SimplePie $b > * @return boolean > */ > public static function sort_items($a, $b) > { > return $a->get_date('U') <= $b->get_date('U'); > } > > I am not saying we should revert the change, but we need to be very > aware of the effect this change will have on PHP7 adoption. The really > nasty part is that even if a big codebase has unit tests covering the > code, unless the unit test actually tests an array with more than 16 > elements, all tests will pass and the application will only fail in > production with production data. And there are no errors or warnings of > any sort either that will help people track this down. > > This will need to be front and center in the UPGRADING doc with an > explanation about how to write a proper ordering function.
Should we add E_STRICT for cases when comparison-function returns non-integer value? Having it in stable version should help to fix such anti-patterns in a long-run -- Alexey Zakhlestin CTO at Grids.by/you https://github.com/indeyets PGP key: http://indeyets.ru/alexey.zakhlestin.pgp.asc
signature.asc
Description: Message signed with OpenPGP using GPGMail
