Now talking only about the Tranform Type 4 - Diffie-Hellman Group Transform IDs IANA registry.
Valery Smyslov writes: > Currently exact groups for numbers 1, 2, 14, 15, 16, 17 and 16 are not > defined in IANA. > For me this is inconsistent. Either change two abovementioned lines to: > > 1 768-Bit MODP Group [RFC4306] > 2 1024-Bit MODP Group [RFC4306] > > 14 2048-Bit MODP Group [RFC3526] > 15 3072-Bit MODP Group [RFC3526] > 16 4096-Bit MODP Group [RFC3526] > 17 6144-Bit MODP Group [RFC3526] > 18 8192-Bit MODP Group [RFC3526] Hmm... I think the IANA registry should really list these out, instead of using range to reference to the RFCs. I think we should fix the IANA registry so the group names will match the section / appendix names in the appropriate RFCs and where there would not be any range allocations. The resulting IANA registry would be like this: ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Registry Name: Transform Type 4 - Diffie-Hellman Group Transform IDs Reference: [RFC4306] Registration Procedures: Expert Review Registry: Number Name Reference ------------ ---------------------------------- --------- 0 NONE [RFC4306] 1 Group 1 - 768 Bit MODP Group [RFC4306] 2 Group 2 - 1024 Bit MODP Group [RFC4306] 3-4 Reserved [RFC4306] 5 1536-bit MODP Group [RFC3526] 6-13 Unassigned [RFC4306] 14 2048-bit MODP Group [RFC3526] 15 3072-bit MODP Group [RFC3526] 16 4096-bit MODP Group [RFC3526] 17 6144-bit MODP Group [RFC3526] 18 8192-bit MODP Group [RFC3526] 19 256-bit random ECP group [RFC4753] 20 384-bit random ECP group [RFC4753] 21 521-bit random ECP group [RFC4753] 22 1024-bit MODP Group with 160-bit [RFC5114] Prime Order Subgroup 23 2048-bit MODP Group with 224-bit [RFC5114] Prime Order Subgroup 24 2048-bit MODP Group with 256-bit [RFC5114] Prime Order Subgroup 25 192-bit Random ECP Group [RFC5114] 26 224-bit Random ECP Group [RFC5114] 27-1023 Unassigned [RFC4306] 1024-65535 Private use [RFC4306] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Unless anybody objects, I will be requesting IANA to make the change next week. -- kivi...@iki.fi _______________________________________________ IPsec mailing list IPsec@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ipsec